1986 NSCA Division II All-American Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kathy Slaten | Cal State Northridge |
| Pitcher | Pam Clay | Stephen F. Austin |
| Pitcher | Debbie Tidy | Sacred Heart |
| Catcher | Penni Lewis | Stephen F. Austin |
| First Base | Jean Millen | Bloomsburg |
| Second Base | Julie Thomas | Sam Houston State |
| Third Base | Tracy Alcorn | Akron |
| Shortstop | Sandy Mader | Sam Houston State |
| Outfield | Barbara Jordan | Cal State Northridge |
| Outfield | Lori Doffing | Mankato State |
| Outfield | Stellis Castro | Stephen F. Austin |
| DP/Utility | Joanne Graham | Sam Houston State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Trish Konable | Northeast Missouri State |
| Pitcher | Susan Kocher | Bloomsburg |
| Pitcher | Laurie Salo | UC Davis |
| Catcher | Kecia Gorman | Cal Poly SLO |
| First Base | Deb Gildersleeve | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Second Base | Daren Hertzler | Bloomsburg |
| Third Base | Joanne Ode | Augustana |
| Shortstop | Lisa Houk | Cal Poly SLO |
| Outfield | Jill Hancock | Cal Poly SLO |
| Outfield | Beth Greig | Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Holly Nuber | Stephen F. Austin |
| DP/Utility | Nifty Heggie | Springfield |
