1989 NSCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Shelley Brown | Allegheny |
| Pitcher | Christia Mohan | Eastern Connecticut State |
| Pitcher | Danielle Kittelson | Luther |
| First Base | Jill Herman | Trenton State |
| Second Base | Linda Giarrusso | Montclair State |
| Third Base | Diane Klueg | Trenton State |
| Shortstop | Pam McCreesh | Trenton State |
| Outfield | Penny Whiteman | Allegheny |
| Outfield | Donna Grooks | Montclair State |
| Outfield | Leanne Shoop | Eastern Connecticut State |
| DP/Utility | Lynn Rocheleau | Eastern Connecticut State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Dianna Moreno | UC San Diego |
| Pitcher | Jill Marghella | Trenton State |
| Catcher |
Lisa Costello | Trenton State |
| First Base | Debbie Macejka | Allegheny |
| Second Base |
Kenise Lamontagne | Eastern Connecticut State |
| Third Base | Kate Titus | Muskingum |
| Shortstop | Stacey O'Reiley | St. Thomas |
| Outfield | Patrice Deltie | St. Thomas |
| Outfield | Tammy Kuester | Wisconsin-Stevens Point |
| Outfield | Andrea Peters | Montclair State |
| DP/Utility | Teva Eiler | Allegheny |
