Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division
1994 Louisville Slugger/NSCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Amy Haeder | Buena Vista |
| Pitcher | Laurie Machuga | Allegheny |
| Pitcher | Heather White | Buena Vista |
| Catcher | Kara Gilligan | Rowan |
| First Base | Angela Constantine | Bridgewater State |
| Second Base | Jennifer Flinn | Montclair State |
| Third Base | Michelle Carlson | Trenton State |
| Shortstop | Kerry Barnett | Ohio Northern |
| Outfield | JoAnn Heckethorn | Trenton State |
| Outfield | Rachel Hudak | Trenton State |
| Outfield | Rachel Butler | Alma |
| DP/Utility | Robin Selbst | Trenton State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kate Enochs | Illinois Benedictine |
| Pitcher | Peggyann Coker | Rowan |
| Catcher |
Kristi Kuchinski | Montclair State |
| First Base | Michelle Tesdahl | Buena Vista |
| Second Base |
Megan Coe | Buena Vista |
| Second Base | Mindy Everhart | Ohio Northern |
| Third Base | Heidi Kerian | Buena Vista |
| Shortstop | Jeanine Bleau | Ithaca |
| Outfield | Wendy Long | Messiah |
| Outfield | Laurie Byington | Hope |
| Outfield | Keri O'Meara | Montclair State |
| DP/Utility |
Kelly LeFevre | Aurora |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Marci Whitehead | Messiah |
| Pitcher | Becky Koenig | Trenton State |
| Catcher | Jen Jacobs | Allegheny |
| First Base | Jenny Madden | Illinois Benedictine |
| First Base | Jami Musey | Rowan |
| Second Base | Amy Trench | Illinois Benedictine |
| Third Base | Chris Postler | Wittenberg |
| Shortstop | Joy Pittner | Rowan |
| Outfield | Katie Anderson | Illinois Benedictine |
| Outfield | Robin Reed | Illinois Wesleyan |
| Outfield |
Laree Reynolds | California Lutheran |
| DP/Utility | Jodi Robinson |
Allegheny |
