1997 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Sharon Ormsbee | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Pitcher | Kelly Schade | Simpson (IA) |
| Catcher | Jerrilyn Acevedo | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Catcher | Dee Wischmeier | Simpson (IA) |
| First Base | Jami Musey | Rowan (NJ) |
| Second Base | Julie Backof | Western Maryland |
| Third Base | Randi Carine | Wheaton (MA) |
| Shortstop | Stephanie Allocco | Rowan (NJ) |
| Outfield | Jennifer Citarella | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Outfield | Beth Cwinski | Aurora (IL) |
| Outfield | Alicia Sanchez | College of New Jersey |
| Designated Player | Jenny Garin | St. Mary's (MN) |
| Utility |
Janetta Trecrone |
Ursinus (PA) |
| At-Large | Kelly King | St. Mary's (MN) |
| At-Large | Shauna Koolhaus | Calvin (MI) |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Becky Pierce | Alma (MI) |
| Pitcher | Sue Spielbauer | William Penn (IA) |
| Catcher | Julie Di Fatta | California Lutheran |
| Catcher | Michelle Tarzia | Western Connecticut State |
| First Base | Stephanie Carew | Chapman (CA) |
| Second Base | Tara Wisz | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Third Base | Amy Kelce | William Penn (IA) |
| Shortstop | June Maloney | Cortland State (NY) |
| Outfield | Cassie Cunningham | Capital (OH) |
| Outfield | Melanie Harriff | Calvin (MI) |
| Outfield | Tiffany Miller | Rowan (NJ) |
| Designated Player |
Wendy Saladino | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Utility | Jennifer Tate | Wittenberg (OH) |
| At-Large | Jessica Johnson | Wheaton (MA) |
| At-Large | Anita DeFeo | College of New Jersey |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Melissa Maxwell | Rowan (NJ) |
| Pitcher |
Kara Stanley | Central (IA) |
| Pitcher | Amy Wallace | Wheaton (IL) |
| Catcher | Sunny Montas | College of New Jersey |
| Catcher | Dina Terceira | Wheaton (MA) |
| First Base |
Jill Schoenike | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| Second Base | Angie Adams | Adrian (MI) |
| Second Base |
Jamie Porter | Wartburg (IA) |
| Outfield | Nicole Cefaratti | Buffalo State (NY) |
| Outfield | Kim Griffin | Simpson (IA) |
| Outfield | Jassamine Maiben | Chapman (CA) |
| Outfield |
Karri Meinen | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| Designated Player | Kim Sears | Wheaton (MA) |
| Utility | Bobbi McCallister | Upper Iowa |
