1999 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division II All-American Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Christina Caldwell | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| Pitcher | Wendy Hurst | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Pitcher | Natalie Pry | Ashland (OH) |
| Catcher | Audra Thomas | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| Catcher | Megan Hunsinger | Bloomsburg (PA) |
| First Base | Julie Eggert | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| Second Base | Melissa McWilliams | Morningside (IA) |
| Third Base | Darcie Berry | Nebraska-Kearney |
| Shortstop | Stacey Dell'Anno | Merrimack (MA) |
| Outfield | Sunny Litteral | Ashland (OH) |
| Outfield | Jamie Peterson | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Outfield | Tracy Porter | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Outfield | Chrissa Landwehr | Augustana (SD) |
| Designated Player | Lane Davis | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Utility | Carrie Newton | Columbus State (GA) |
| At-Large | Stephanie Caldwell | Barry (FL) |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Jessame Kendall |
Humboldt State (CA) |
| Pitcher | Julie Fromm | North Dakota State |
| Pitcher | Jenn Connolly | Merrimack (MA) |
| Catcher | Blake Baskin | West Florida |
| Catcher | Julie Cobb | Central Missouri State |
| First Base | Julie Phipps | Assumption (MA) |
| First Base | Kim Biskup | Grand Valley State (MI) |
| Second Base | Jamie McLaughlin | Gannon (PA) |
| Third Base | Mary Gramenz | North Dakota State |
| Third Base | Shelli Maher | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Shortstop | Audrey Williams | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Outfield | Cathy Jacobson | Texas Woman's |
| Outfield | Shannon Ross | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| Outfield | Stephanie DeLucia | Assumption (MA) |
| Outfield | Jody Gifford | Ferris State (MI) |
| Designated Player | Ericka McClintock |
Columbus State (GA) |
| Utility | Holly Hall | California (PA) |
| At-Large | Jenny Hill |
Augustana (SD) |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Julianne Coleman | Florida Southern |
| Pitcher | Missy Paterson | Coker (SC) |
| Pitcher | Amanda Kelly | Nebraska-Kearney |
| Catcher | Amanda Jennings | Wayne State (MI) |
| Catcher | Megan Keesling | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Catcher | Kristine Botto | Massachusetts-Lowell |
| First Base | April Tursky | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Second Base | Jarnett Lono | Hawaii Pacific |
| Third Base | Carolyn McGowan | American International (MA) |
| Shortstop | Nickie Engelbrecht | Texas Woman's |
| Outfield | Cherene Hiesl | East Central (OK) |
| Outfield | Meaggan Wilton | California (PA) |
| Outfield | Sheryl Marshall | Merrimack (MA) |
| Outfield | Lyrissa Sagawa | Hawaii Pacific |
| Designated Player | Sarah Gagnon |
Massachusetts, Lowell |
| Utlity | Courtney Noble | Wayne State (MI) |
| At-Large | Monica Hashiguchi |
Southern Colorado |
