2000 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Paige Stamp |
Coe (IA) |
| Pitcher | Becky Pierce | Alma (MI) |
| Catcher | Shannon Fritzke | Pacific Lutheran (WA) |
| Catcher | Kristin Furdon | Ithaca (NY) |
| First Base | Devon Searfoss | College of New Jersey |
| Second Base | Tara Wisz | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Third Base | Donell Hotze | Central (IA) |
| Shortstop | Stephanie Allocco | Rowan (NJ) |
| Shortstop | Brandee Brower | Alma (MI) |
| Outfield | Toni Milito | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Outfield | Leslie Prochaska | Chapman (CA) |
| Outfield | Cassie Cunningham | Capital (OH) |
| Designated Player |
Mandy Carnes | Muskingum (OH) |
| Utility | Jill Hocking | St. Mary's (MN) |
| At-Large (P) | Linsey Buendia | Chapman (CA) |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Robin Bimson |
Ithaca (NY) |
| Pitcher | Heidi Bergstrom | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| Catcher | Annie Van Wetzinga | Central (IA) |
| Catcher | Holly Morris | Roanoke (VA) |
| First Base | Laura Remia | Ithaca (NY) |
| Second Base | Amber Ridnour | Simpson (IA) |
| Third Base | Krissy Medino | College of New Jersey |
| Shortstop | Adrianne Cole | Mount Union (OH) |
| Outfield | Lauren Hertzberg | William Paterson (NJ) |
| Outfield | Jill Almansberger | Geneseo State (NY) |
| Outfield | Angie Wright | St. Mary's (MN) |
| Designated Player |
Alisson Gerrish | Springfield (MA) |
| Utility | Diane Naugle | William Paterson (NJ) |
| At-Large (P) | Melissa Korb | Pacific Lutheran (WA) |
| At-Large (1B) | Heather Peters | Chapman (CA) |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Mandy Schenck |
College of New Jersey |
| Pitcher |
Jen Segner | Muskingum (OH) |
| Pitcher | Jamie Elias | Rowan (NJ) |
| Pitcher | Nan Duga |
Springfield (MA) |
| Catcher | Lisa Schueler | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| Catcher |
Kathryn Nordin |
Alma (MI) |
| Catcher | Lis Drake | Tufts (MA) |
| Third Base |
Traci Simons | Savannah A&D (GA) |
| Third Base |
Danielle Guccia | St. John Fisher (NY) |
| Third Base | Kari Whitney | Roanoke (VA) |
| Shortstop |
Erin Bridges | UC San Diego |
| Shortstop |
Alison Rohdy | Coe (IA) |
| Outfield | Dawn Lopez | Chapman (CA) |
| Outfield | Alex Lamont | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Outfield | Sara Brookhart | Simpson (IA) |
