Louisville Slugger/NFCA 2003 NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Jayne Miller | Columbia College (Mo.) |
| P | Melissa Passley | University of Mobile (Ala.) |
| P | Auburn Sigurdson | Simon Fraser (B.C.) |
| C | Jill Vaughn | Oklahoma City |
| IF | Rachel Alkire | Azusa Pacific (Calif.) |
| IF | Cheryl Bolding | Point Loma Nazarene (Calif.) |
| IF | Amanda Jensen | Olivet Nazarene (Ill.) |
| IF | Shannon Rossiter | Simon Fraser (B.C.) |
| IF | Maria Soto | University of Mobile (Ala.) |
| OF | Tara Diene | William Woods (Mo.) |
| OF | Shannon Kohl | Walsh (Ohio) |
| OF | Molly Peterson | Bellevue (Neb.) |
| UT | Mariangee Bogado | Thomas (Ga.) |
| At-Large | Kena Freeman | Oklahoma Baptist |
| At-Large | Leslie Ludlow | Point Noma Nazarene (Calif.) |
| At-Large | Erin Thomas | Simon Fraser (B.C.) |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Leah Gronberg | Union (Tenn.) |
| P | Miranda van der Voort | Point Noma Nazarene (Calif.) |
| C | Erin Crumpstone | Simon Fraser (B.C.) |
| IF | Lauren Gidcumb | Olivet Nazarene (Ill.) |
| IF | Jessica Oleson | Oklahoma City |
| IF | Katy Thurber | Oklahoma Baptist |
| OF | Tara Hollar | St. Xavier (Ill.) |
| OF | Amy Nanson | Point Noma Nazarene (Calif.) |
| OF | Rachel Schill | Simon Fraser (B.C.) |
| OF | Alison Sellers | Spring Hill (Ala.) |
| DP | Leah Woldyk | Spring Arbor (Mich.) |
| DP | Danielle DeLeon | Spring Hill (Ala.) |
| UT | Jessica Rapoza | Point Noma Nazarene (Calif.) |
| UT | Kim Hopkins (Ga.) | Thomas (Ga.) |
| At-Large | Rachel Werner | Houston Baptist (Texas) |
| At-Large | Stephanie Dixon | Thomas (Ga.) |
| At-Large | Denisse Fuenmayor | University of Mobile (Ala.) |
| At-Large | Laura Hess | Houston Baptist (Texas) |
