2004 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Erica Hoyt |
Muskingum |
| Pitcher | Meagan Hennessy |
Moravian |
| Catcher | Angela Gonzales |
East Texas Baptist |
| Catcher | Nicole Loudin |
Baldwin - Wallace |
| First Base | Liz Swary |
Washington (Mo.) |
| Second Base | Brooke Peterdozzi |
Cabrini |
| Third Base |
Kelley Silagyi |
La Verne |
| Shortstop | Heather Bortz |
Moravian |
| Outfield | Dallas Slosjarik |
Christopher Newport |
| Outfield | Erin Bravo |
Wisconsin - Whitewater |
| Outfield | Tonya Minor |
East Texas Baptist |
| Designated Player | Allison Ratcliff | East Texas Baptist |
| Utility | Audrey Kuhn |
SUNY - Geneseo |
| At-Large | Janet Nagle | St. Thomas |
| At-Large | Jewel Koury |
Pacific Lutheran |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Stephanie Adamshick |
Cortland State |
| Pitcher | Hannah Roberts | University of Chicago |
| Catcher | Nikki Conway | St. Thomas |
| Catcher | Erin Carson | Alma |
| First Base | Maria Zangardi | King's College |
| Second Base | Linsey Longstreth | Ohio Wesleyan |
| Third Base | Audrey Lenoch | Gustavus Adolphus |
| Shortstop | Michelle Wong | St. Thomas |
| Outfield | Allison Lange | Bluffton |
| Outfield | April Rader | Muskingum |
| Outfield | Lauren Batson | Christopher Newport |
| Designated Player |
Caroline Cubbage | Lynchburg |
| Utility | Mallory McKinney | Wisconsin - Eau Claire |
| At-Large | Brynn Hasse | Illinois Wesleyan |
| At-Large | Jamie Anzaldi | Ramapo |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| At-Large | Nicole Blubaugh |
Muskingum |
| At-Large | Jennifer Pietrowski | Mary Hardin - Baylor |
| At-Large | Maggie Shaeffer | Arcadia |
| At-Large | Christy Shipley | East Texas Baptist |
| At-Large | Erin Kegley | Wisconsin - Superior |
| At-Large | Lacey Lister | Salisbury |
| At-Large | Amanda Gage | Hamline |
| At-Large | Laurel Sagartz | Washington (Mo.) |
| At-Large | Leigh Ann LaFave | Alma |
| At-Large | Liz Gluck | Williams |
| At-Large | Shauna Jellison | Muskingum |
| At-Large | Jackie Demling | Wheaton |
| At-Large | Rose Reichart | Ripon |
| At-Large | Sarah Betts | Bluffton |
| At-Large | Lara Stone | Cortland State |
