2005 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Ashley Lanz |
Simon Fraser |
| P | Rachel Werner |
Houston Baptist |
| P | Candice Thomas |
Cal Baptist |
| p | Dana Askins |
Science & Arts |
| p | Steph Christner |
William Penn |
| C | Cat Calvert |
Oklahoma City |
| IF | Kelly Golden |
Lee |
| IF | Mayret Perez |
Mobile |
| IF | Lindsey Bredar |
Bellvue |
| IF | Danielle Pope |
Union |
| IF | Kristen Hernandez |
Cal Baptist |
| OF | Rachel Schill |
Simon Fraser |
| OF | Brittany Cobb |
North Georgia |
| OF | Vanessa Shelton |
Eastern Oregon |
| UT | Jill Vaughn |
Oklahoma City |
| UT | Tami Trujillo |
Cal Baptist |
|
|
||
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Beth Willis | North Georgia |
| P | Jamie Pendley | USAO |
| P | Rachel Werner | Houston Baptist |
| C | Jill Vaughn | Oklahoma City |
| IF | Stephanie Dixon | Thomas |
| IF | Ali Caviglia | Simon Fraser |
| IF | Lynsey Thompson | North Georgia |
| OF | Jennifer Byrd | Thomas |
| OF | Brenda Box | Mobile |
| OF | Cassandra Berger | Olivet Nazarene |
| OF | Alexis Powell | Point Loma Nazarene |
| DP | Cheri Wood | Houston Baptist |
| UT | Dana Kelly | Spring Hill |
| At-Large | Kelly Kalish | Point Loma Nazarene |
| At-Large | Charli Duff | Trevecca Nazarene |
| At-Large | Laura Heise | St. Scholastica |
