2007 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division II All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kristin Erb | Lock Haven |
| Pitcher | Amber Browning | Columbus State |
| Pitcher | Megan Brown | Florida Southern |
| Catcher | Amber Lanier | Columbus State |
| Catcher | Christie Softy | Long Island University - C.W. Post |
| First Base | Stephanie Denlinger | Kutztown |
| Second Base | Vanessa Rodriguez | San Francisco State |
| Third Base | Carmen Paez | Florida Gulf Coast |
| Shortstop | Stephanie Bour | Cameron |
| Outfield | Kandace Kubat | Angelo State |
| Outfield | Casie Hanson | University of North Dakota |
| Outfield | Sarah Kohlbrenner | Florida Southern |
| Designated Player | Kaycee Taylor | Angelo State |
| Utility Player | Katie Veltri | Nova Southeastern |
| At-Large | Lizzy Prescott | Humboldt State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Courtney Reed | Emporia State |
| Pitcher | Kari Galm | Angelo State |
| Pitcher | Samantah Yodowitz | Long Island University - C.W. Post |
| Catcher | Kelcy Walker | St. Mary's |
| Catcher | Marissa Slattery | Humboldt State |
| First Base | Natalie Galletly | Humboldt State |
| Second Base | Kandi Wieberg | University of Missouri - Rolla |
| Third Base | Megan Davison | Emporia State |
| Shortstop | Jaclyn Corroto | Gannon |
| Outfield | Megan Law | Cal State Stanislaus |
| Outfield | Shay Slater | USC-Upstate |
| Outfield | Heidi Gibbs | USC-Upstate |
| Designated Player | Vanessa Flores | USC-Upstate |
| Utility | Ashley Fitzgerald | Kutztown |
| At-Large | Malissa Magee | St. Mary's |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kaitlin Colosimo | Southern Illinois Univ. - Edwardsville |
| Catcher | Jesica Strickland | University of South Carolina - Aiken |
| First Base | Meredith Heckel | University of Arkansas - Monticello |
| Second Base | Meghan Ward | University of Mary |
| Third Base | Keidra Baitey | Georgia College & State University |
| Shortstop | Rachel Adams | University of Central Missouri |
| Outfield | Ashley Winter | University of Missouri - Rolla |
| At-Large | Molly Yetman | Wayne State |
| At-Large | Stacy Haney | Univ. of Colorado - Colorado Springs |
| At-Large | Alex Acosta | Valdosta State |
| At-Large | Brittney Cargill | Angelo State |
| At-Large | Carolyn Cameron | Humboldt State |
| At-Large | Nicole Hartfield | San Francisco State |
