1986 NSCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Stacey Johnson | Louisiana Tech |
| Pitcher | Amy Unterbrink | Indiana |
| Pitcher | Susana LeFebvre | Cal State Fullerton |
| Catcher | Alicia Seegret | Michigan |
| First Base | Kathy Dyer | New Mexico |
| Second Base | Alison Stowell | Cal Poly Pomona |
| Third Base | Cindy Cooper | Texas A&M |
| Shortstop | Leslie Kanter | South Florida |
| Outfield | Kathy Escarcega | Arizona State |
| Outfield | Chenita Rogers | Cal State Fullerton |
| Outfield | Karleen Moore | Indiana |
| DP/Utility | Tracy Bunge | Kansas |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Lori Sippel | Nebraska |
| Pitcher | Melanie Parrent | Fresno State |
| Pitcher | Rhonda Wheatley | Cal Poly Pomona |
| Catcher | Kelly Downs | Kansas |
| First Base | Gena Strang | Fresno State |
| Second Base | Lori Richens | Nebraska |
| Third Base | Mary Hammen | Oklahoma State |
| Shortstop | Kelly Smith | Utah State |
| Outfield | Sheila Connolly | Kansas |
| Outfield | Kris Schmidt | Missouri |
| Outfield | Sally Mahr | Massachusetts |
| DP/Utility | Barb Drake | Minnesota |
