1986 NSCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kim Durocher | Eastern Connecticut State |
| Pitcher | Darsi Doyle | Luther |
| Pitcher | Marge Theobald | Montclair State |
| First Base | Sandy Fisher | Kean |
| Second Base | Gia Celularo | Allegheny |
| Third Base | Tracey Warren | Trenton State |
| Shortstop | Carol Buckheit | Ithaca |
| Outfield | Donna Brooks | Montclair State |
| Outfield | Trish Wodatch | Eastern Connecticut State |
| Outfield | Melissa Vogel | Allegheny |
| DP/Utility | Diane Klueg | Trenton State |
| DP/Utility | Amy Baudoin | Aurora |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Lisa Wyner | Methodist |
| Pitcher | Cindy Woodward | Trenton State |
| Catcher | Cindy Messer | Central |
| First Base | Stacey Peterson | Aurora |
| Second Base |
Charlotte Shepherd | Aurora |
| Third Base | Jeannie Demers | Buena Vista |
| Shortstop | Nancy Nelson | Allegheny |
| Outfield | Maria Kramer | Ithaca |
| Outfield | Andrea Peters | Montclair State |
| Outfield | Anne Westerkamp | Benedictine |
| Outfield | Julie Curtis | Whittier |
| DP/Utility | Marcia Fichtelman | Ohio Northern |
