1986 NSCA NJCAA All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Melinda Barton | Wabash Valley |
| Pitcher | Cami Pollard | Snow |
| Pitcher | Michele Chia | Crowder |
| Catcher | Sherri Lamar | Eastern Arizona |
| Infield | Brenda Gilles | Illinois Central |
| Infield | Tammy McKinney | Central Illinois |
| Infield | Norma Natividad | Pima |
| Infield | Joanne Webster | Onondaga |
| Outfield | Pam Ernst | Illinois Central |
| Outfield | Sandy Long | Lake Michigan |
| Outfield | Kori Morris | Eastern |
| Outfield | Bekki Turner | Crowder |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Chris Barry | Onondaga |
| Pitcher | Kim Beaty | Arizona Western |
| Pitcher | Jenny Schweikert | Walforf |
| Catcher | Patsy Rudie | Normandale |
| Infield | Kim Dean | Crowder |
| Infield | Cathy Dryer | Arizona Western |
| Infield | Tammy Palmatier | Kishwaukee |
| Infield | Rita Swenor | Lansing |
| Outfield | Barb Barry | Ulster County |
| Outfield | Karen Borowiak | Erie |
| Outfield | Terry Fritz | Illinois Central |
| Outfield | Sharon McAllister | Anne Arundel |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Carole Buczek | Charles County |
| Pitcher | Sharon Sullivan | Morris |
| Pitcher | Maureen Fritz | St. Louis |
| Catcher | Kim Foglesong | Carl Sandburg |
| Catcher | Andrea Wilson | Mitchell |
| Infield | Diane Kelly | Mercer County |
| Infield | Beth Ann Kross | Moraine Valley |
| Infield | Sue Pyles | St. Louis |
| Outfield | Tara Buryska | Rochester |
