1987 NSCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Laurie Sutton | Central |
| Pitcher | Dina DeAquino | Montclair State |
| Pitcher | Donna O'Connell | Trenton State |
| First Base | Kris Thompson | Central |
| Second Base | Gia Celularo | Allegheny |
| Third Base | Tracey Warren | Trenton State |
| Shortstop | Anne Westerkamp | Illinois Benedictine |
| Outfield | Melissa Vogel | Allegheny |
| Outfield | Sandy Workman | Illinois Benedictine |
| Outfield | Julie Quirin | Buena Vista |
| Utility | Diane Klueg | Trenton State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Shelly Brown | Allegheny |
| Pitcher | Christi Mohan | Eastern Connecticut State |
| First Base |
Tracey Burke | Montclair State |
| Second Base | Linda Giarusso | Montclair State |
| Third Base |
Chela Castano | Redlands |
| Shortstop | Pam McCreesh | Trenton State |
| Outfield | Julie Curtis | Whittier |
| Outfield | Andrea Peters | Montclair State |
| Outfield | Laura Redik | LaVerne |
| Utility | Cathy McGillicuddy | Eastern Connecticut State |
