1989 NSCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Katie Wiese | Oregon |
| Pitcher | Terry Carpenter | Fresno State |
| Pitcher | Michele Smith | Oklahoma State |
| Catcher | Lisa Harvey | Oklahoma State |
| First Base | Missy Coombes | Cal State Fullerton |
| Second Base | Michelle Delloso | South Carolina |
| Third Base | Janice Parks | UCLA |
| Shortstop | Shari Johnson | Oklahoma State |
| Outfield | Jill Justin | Northern Illinois |
| Outfield | Carey Hess | Cal State Fullerton |
| Outfield | Tricia Popowski | South Carolina |
| DP/Utility | Jenny Allard | Michigan |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Carie Dever | Fresno State |
| Pitcher | Stefni Whitton | Southwestern Louisiana |
| Pitcher | Debbie Nichols | Louisiana Tech |
| Catcher | Delana Lightfoot | Texas-Arlington |
| First Base | Julie Lilifeborg | Western Michigan |
| Second Base | Beth Bull | Central Michigan |
| Third Base | Karla Ismay | New Mexico |
| Shortstop | Tiffany Daniels | Florida State |
| Outfield | Shanna Flynn | UCLA |
| Outfield | Jenny Condon | Iowa State |
| Outfield | Shontan Garr | Sam Houston State |
| DP/Utility | Kim Manning | Oregon |
