NSCA 1989 NAIA All-America Team
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Karen Knox | IUPUI |
| Pitcher | Joann Tobin | West Florida |
| Catcher | Candy Aplin | Tri State |
| Catcher | Missy Cromer | West Florida |
| Infield | Patricia Murphy | Bloomfield |
| Infield | Missy Michelle | IUPUI |
| Infield | Wendy Sackman | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Infield | Pam Hosp | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Outfield | Bonita Rushing | West Florida |
| Outfield | Kelley Dockx | Bloomfield |
| Outfield | Tracy Burbach | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Outfield | Eva Smith | Tri State |
