1991 NSCA Division II All-American Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Jacki Blake | Chapman |
| Pitcher | Julie Krauth | Augustana |
| Pitcher | Kristin Jacobs | Portland State |
| Catcher | Marty Laudato | Bloomsburg |
| First Base | Ferris Grund | Augustana |
| Second Base | Chrissy Teresi | Florida Southern |
| Second Base | Cheryl Lutes | Cal Poly |
| Third Base | Sandy Olivas | Chapman |
| Shortstop | Kellie Robinson | Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Janet Buckheit | Bloomsburg |
| Outfield | Amy Van Allen | Cal State Bakersfield |
| Outfield | Lisa Houska | Missouri Southern |
| DP/Utility | Lori Shelly | Bloomsburg |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Amy Boyd | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Pitcher | Cindy Johansen | Florida Southern |
| Pitcher | Alice Marler | Southeast Missouri State |
| Catcher | Diane Miller | Missouri Southern |
| FIrst Base | Lisa Ebersole | Sonoma State |
| Second Base | Angie Hopkins | Augustana |
| Third Base | Karen Hudson | Southeast Missouri State |
| Shortstop | Kim Kouri | Augustana |
| Outfield | Cynthia Macom | Portland State |
| Outfield | Tangie Burns | Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Michelle Palmer | Sacred Heart |
| DP/Utility | Michelle Cleeton | Southern Illinois-Edwardsville |
