1991 NSCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Jennifer LoPresti | Trenton State |
| Pitcher | Jamie Mahnke | Central |
| Catcher | Andrea Haight | Augsburg |
| First Base | Jeanne Hengemuhle | Trenton State |
| Second Base | Lynn Spirko | Trenton State |
| Second Base | Christi Van Werden | Central |
| Third Base | Jenny Grower | Mount Union |
| Shortstop | Janet Domino | Trenton State |
| Outfield | Patti Kinghorn | Trenton State |
| Outfield | Danille Seeger | Cortland State |
| Outfield | Penny Whiteman | Allegheny |
| Utility | Marnie LaFeur | Cal State San Bernardino |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Elaine Gratrix | Muhlenberg |
| Pitcher | Kiane Moreno | UC San Diego |
| Pitcher |
Patti Zito | William Paterson |
| Catcher | Andrea Bussler | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| First Base |
Kris Mach | Eastern Connecticut State |
| Second Base | Ronnie Bohm | Allegheny |
| Third Base | Margare Dupuis | William Paterson |
| Shortstop | Carol Christopherson | Aurora |
| Outfield | Stacey Sparks | Millikin |
| Outfield | Laura Stickle | Mount Union |
| Outfield | Jodie Hemmingsen | Luther |
| DP/Utility | Chris Sheaffer | Muskingum |
