1995 Louisville Slugger/NSCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Brooke Wilkins | Hawaii |
| Pitcher | Cheryl Longeway | Southwestern Louisiana |
| Pitcher | Carrie Dolan | Arizona |
| Catcher | Gillian Boxx | California |
| First Base | Amy Chellevold | Arizona |
| Second Base | Jenny Dalton | Arizona |
| Third Base | Jennifer Brundage | UCLA |
| Shortstop | Laura Espinoza | Arizona |
| Outfield | Robyn Yorke | Fresno State |
| Outfield | Laura Berg | Fresno State |
| Outfield | Leah O'Brien | Arizona |
| Designated Player | Kathy Morton | Southwestern Louisiana |
| Utility | Sara Griffin | Michigan |
| At-Large (P) | Kelly Kovach | Michigan |
| At-Large (1B) | Cyndi Parus | UNLV |
| At-Large (SS) | Kim Rodina | UNLV |
| At-Large (C) | Leah Braatz | Arizona |
| At-Large (2B) | Missy Nowak | DePaul |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Terri Kobata | Notre Dame |
| Pitcher | Susie Bugliarello | Cal State Sacramento |
| Pitcher | Whitney Floyd | California |
| Catcher | Tiffany Whittall | Southwestern Louisiana |
| First Base | Stephanie DeFeo | Southwestern Louisiana |
| Second Base | Kelly Howard | UCLA |
| Third Base | Tobin Echo-Hawk | Nebraska |
| Shortstop | Ali Viola | Nebraska |
| Outfield | Sara Mallett | UNLV |
| Outfield | Dana Fulmer | South Carolina |
| Outfield | Lana Jimenez | Southwestern Louisiana |
| Designated Player | Jen Ackley | California |
| Utility | Scia Maumausolo | Cal State Northridge |
| At-Large (P) | Amie Stewart | UNLV |
| At-Large (3B) | Lynn Britton | Southwestern Louisiana |
| At-Large (SS) | Nicole Odom | UCLA |
| At-Large (UT) | Tanya Harding | UCLA |
| At-Large (UT) | Kim Ward | Oklahoma State |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Trinity Johnson | South Carolina |
| Pitcher | Jodi Burch | Illinois State |
| Pitcher | Brea Moore | Oklahoma |
| Catcher | Julie Crandall | UNLV |
| First Base | Alleah Poulson | UCLA |
| Second Base | Chris Zboril | Cal State Fullerton |
| Third Base | Cindy Lawton | Florida State |
| Shortstop | Jen Babik | Princeton |
| Outfield | Andrea D'Innocenzo | Connecticut |
| Outfield | Shamalene Wilson | Florida State |
| Outfield | Rachel Nelson | Minnesota |
| Designated Player | Katie Marten | Notre Dame |
| Utility | Debbie Bilbao | Iowa |
| At-Large (C) | Michelle Venturella | Indiana |
| At-Large (C) | Tina Plew | South Carolina |
| At-Large (OF) | Karie Langelier | Oklahoma State |
| At-Large (1B) | Mandy Pfeiffer | Princeton |
| At-Large (OF) | Tasha Reents | Iowa |
| At-Large (1B) | Kari Knopf | Iowa |
