1995 Louisville Slugger/NSCA Division II All-American Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | April Paoli | Bloomsburg |
| Pitcher | Kelly Rafter | Kennesaw State |
| Pitcher | Gena Weber | UC Davis |
| Catcher | Paula U'Ren |
Augustana |
| Catcher | Jackie Aiken | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| First Base | Shally Lundien | Missouri Southern |
| Second Base | Daniela Paparo | Merrimack |
| Third Base | Tonya Carlisle | Kennesaw State |
| Third Base | Lith Webb | California (PA) |
| Shortstop | Apple Gomez | Humboldt State |
| Shortstop | Jen Lefever | Bloomsburg |
| Outfield | Elisa Bartolo | Florida Tech |
| Outfield | Michelle LeFebvre | Merrimack |
| Outfield | Traci Wood | Florida Southern |
| Designated Player |
Cara Dornstauder | Kennesaw State |
| Utility | Mindi Prince | Morningside |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Andrea Clarke | Missouri Southern |
| Pitcher | Rochelle Dierkes | California (PA) |
| Pitcher | Heather Randolph | Carson-Newman |
| Catcher | Brenda Moffatt | Bloomsburg |
| Catcher | Colleen Thorburn | Kennesaw State |
| First Base | Jen Wagner | California (PA) |
| Second Base | Jill McCaslin | Nebraska-Kearney |
| Third Base | Kathy Mayo | American International |
| Shortstop | Shelly Davis | Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Raffaella Paparo | Merrimack (MA) |
| Outfield | Christine Dillner | California (PA) |
| Outfield | Amber Huse | Southern Indiana |
| Designated Player |
Kathy Hallowell | Shippensburg |
| Utility |
Ginger Daniel | Missouri Southern |
| At-Large | Keri Bianchini | Merrimack (MA) |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kelly Wolfe | Humboldt State |
| Pitcher | Holly Trantham | Missouri Southern |
| Pitcher | Siri Johnson | Augustana |
| Catcher | Suzanne Collins | Cal State Bakersfield |
| Catcher | Lisa DiFulvio | Sacred Heart |
| First Base | Jennifer Fritz | Humboldt State |
| Second Base | Kelly Stilwell | Ashland |
| Third Base | Lori Leonard | Southern Indiana |
| Shortstop | Lisa Hill | Pittsburg State |
| Outfield | Anetra Torres | Humboldt State |
| Outfield | Melissa Grider | Missouri Southern |
| Outfield | Desi Gillman | Ashland |
| Designated Player |
Tracy Carey | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Utility |
Renee LeClerc | American International |
| At-Large | Jo-Lynn Cimino | New Haven |
| At-Large | Tia Vitiritto | Morningside |
