1996 Louisville Slugger/NSCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Heather Meyer | Washington |
| Pitcher | B'Ann Burns | UCLA |
| Pitcher | Cheryl Longeway | USL |
| Catcher | Lety Pineda | Arizona |
| First Base | Michelle Church | Washington |
| Second Base | Jenny Dalton | Arizona |
| Third Base | Christine Kubin | North Carolina |
| Shortstop | Ali Viola | Nebraska |
| Outfield | Alison Johnsen | Arizona |
| Outfield | Shamalene Wilson | Florida State |
| Outfield | Rachel Nelson | Minnesota |
| Designated Player | Lisa Dacquisto | Arizona State |
| Utility | Sara Griffin | Michigan |
| At-Large (P) | Lindsay Parker | Fresno State |
| At-Large (C) | Scia Maumausolo | Cal State Northridge |
| At-Large (SS) | Kendall Richards | Texas A&M |
| At-Large (2B) | Nina Lindenberg | Fresno State |
| At-Large (2B) | Sara Pickering | Washington |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Trinity Johnson | South Carolina |
| Pitcher | Susie Bugliarello | Cal State Sacramento |
| Pitcher | Carrie Dolan | Arizona |
| Catcher | Jennifer Cline | Washington |
| First Base | Alleah Poulson | UCLA |
| Second Base | Cindy Smith | Oklahoma State |
| Third Base | Krista Gomez | Arizona |
| Shortstop | Keri Lemasters | Michigan State |
| Outfield | Rashunda Taylor | Nicholls State |
| Outfield | Amber Hegland | Minnesota |
| Outfield | Chanda Lee | South Carolina |
| Designated Player | Tia Morenz | Hawaii |
| Utility | Jennifer Richardson | Cal State Northridge |
| At-Large (OF) | Brandi Shriver | Arizona |
| At-Large (OF) | Myssi Calkins | Florida State |
| At-Large (P) | Renee Espinoza | Florida State |
| At-Large (P) | Jill Most | Oklahoma |
| At-Large (3B) | Patti Raduenz | Michigan State |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Whitney Floyd | California |
| Pitcher | Audrey West | Boston |
| Pitcher | Gina Ugo | Indiana |
| Catcher | Stephenie Little | Oklahoma State |
| First Base | Kari Knopf | Iowa |
| Second Base | Yvette Healy | DePaul |
| Third Base | Julie Adams | UCLA |
| Shortstop | Christy Hebert | Iowa |
| Outfield | Kellyn Tate | Michigan |
| Outfield | Jenifer Henry | Fresno State |
| Outfield | Jaime Foutch | Oklahoma State |
| Designated Player | Katie Marten | Notre Dame |
| Utility | Erin Field | Texas A&M |
| At-Large (3B) | Lynn Britton | USL |
| At-Large (SS) | Kim Rondina | UNLV |
| At-Large (C) | Carolyn Wilson | Pacific |
| At-Large (3B) | Tobin Echo-Hawk | Nebraska |
| At-Large (OF) | Becky Newbry | Washington |
| At-Large (OF) | Robyn Yorke | Fresno State |
