1996 Louisville Slugger/NSCA Division II All-American Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Wendy Wolff | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Pitcher | Gena Weber | UC Davis |
| Pitcher | Jeree Carlson | Morningside |
| Catcher | Staci Albright |
Coker |
| Catcher | Heather Hillstrom | Mankato State |
| First Base | Jen Wagner | California (PA) |
| Second Base | Ramona Arscott | Columbus |
| Third Base | Lith Webb | California (PA) |
| Third Base | Jackie Aiken | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Shortstop | Shelly Davis | Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Traci Wood | Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Sunny Litteral | Ashland |
| Outfield | Raffaella Paparo | Merrimack |
| Designated Player | Bobbi Kapla | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Utility | Mindi Prince | Morningside |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kelly Rafter | Kennesaw State |
| Pitcher | Danielle Penner | California (PA) |
| Pitcher | Kelly Stone | Cal State Bakersfield |
| Catcher | Heather Hunter | UC Davis |
| Catcher | Gabbie Elder-Roeser | Barry |
| First Base | Cara Dornstauder | Kennesaw State |
| Second Base | Jessie Johnson | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Third Base | Carolyn McGowan | American International |
| Shortstop | Lorie Erie | Kutztown |
| Outfield | Traci Meade | Cal State Bakersfield |
| Outfield | Elisa Bartolo | Florida Institute of Technology |
| Outfield | Jenni Upenieks | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Designated Player |
Courtney Watson | Humboldt State |
| Utility |
Andrea Peters | Emporia State |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Denise Peterson | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Pitcher | Lisa McNeley | Florida Southern |
| Pitcher | Mandee Berg | Central Missouri State |
| Pitcher | Lisa Howell | UC Davis |
| Catcher | Bobbi Kapla | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Catcher | Ginger Daniel | Missouri Southern State |
| First Base | Jennifer Fritz | Humboldt State |
| Second Base | Jill McCaslin | Nebraska-Kearney |
| Third Base | Susan Punzo | Central Missouri State |
| Shortstop | Jill Johnson | Mankato State |
| Outfield | Brantley Mack | Lander |
| Outfield | Chris Torrez | Washburn |
| Outfield | Jessica Schuler | Kutztown |
| Designated Player |
Sue Weihs | Central Missouri State |
| Utility | Melissa Laing | Shippensburg |
