1996 Louisville Slugger/NSCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Christy Guidorizzi | Chapman |
| Pitcher | Katie Enochs | Illinois Benedictine |
| Catcher | Kathy Donovan | Chapman |
| Catcher | Sunny Montas | Trenton State |
| First Base | Jami Musey | Rowan |
| Second Base | Karen Carpenter | Plymouth State |
| Third Base | Wendy Moore | Hope |
| Shortstop | Joy Pittner | Rowan |
| Outfield | Jessamine Maiben | Chapman |
| Outfield | Crystal Feo | Rowan |
| Outfield | Jennifer Citarella | Montclair State |
| DP/Utility | Jen Goodwin | Bridgewater State |
| At-Large (UT) | Deanna Hunt |
Buffalo State |
| At-Large (1B) | Anita DeFeo | Trenton State |
| At-Large (SS) | Keri Camuso | Springfield |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Missey Allen | Central |
| Pitcher | Laurie Machuga | Allegheny |
| Catcher | Amy Moeckel | Hope |
| Catcher | Amy Sasin | Bridgewater State |
| First Base | Rebecca Bliss | Springfield |
| Second Base | Tracy Little | California Lutheran |
| Third Base | Michelle Andre | Rowan |
| Shortstop | Lisa Cancilla | Chapman |
| Outfield | Laurie Byington | Hope |
| Outfield | Karen Bode | Aurora |
| Outfield | Alicia Sanchez | Trenton State |
| DP/Utility |
Heidi Stevens | California Lutheran |
| At-Large (P) | Robyn Baron | Montclair State |
| At-Large (SS) | Sarah Marchetti | Eastern Connecticut State |
| At-Large (1B) | Lynette Mullen | Central |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Shauna Koolhaas | Calvin |
| Pitcher | Melissa Maxwell | Rowan |
| Pitcher | Jessica Regan | Messiah |
| Pitcher | Karen Stefanowicz | Trenton State |
| Pitcher | Nicki Swan | Ithaca |
| Catcher | Jerrilyn Acevedo | Montclair State |
| Third Base | Bekkah Snider | California Lutheran |
| Shortstop | Suzanne Brion | Wisconsin-Stout |
| Shortstop | Jenny Coyle | Augsburg |
| Shortstop | Ro Guzzi | Montclair State |
| Outfield |
Andrea Franck | Western Connecticut State |
| Utility |
Meredith Sherman | Luther |
| At-Large (SS) | Stephanie Tharp | William Penn |
| At-Large (UT) |
Janetta Trecroce | Ursinus |
| At-Large (2B) | Meredith Wessman | Messiah |
