1996 Louisville Slugger/NSCA NJCAA All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Sophia Contreraz | Palm Beach (FL) |
| Pitcher | Vaneesa Herberger | Daytona Beach (FL) |
| Pitcher | Brandi Nickell | Johnson County (KS) |
| Catcher | Jamie Moore | Palm Beach (FL) |
| Catcher | Shelli Balch | Crowder (MO) |
| Infield | Crystl Bustos | Palm Beach (FL) |
| Infield | Danielle Preece | Palm Beach (FL) |
| Infield | Karla Contryman | Phoenix (AZ) |
| Infield | Crystal Conn | Ranger (TX) |
| Infield | Kelly Uhde | Indian Hills (IA) |
| Outfield | Holly Mitchell | St. Louis/Meramec (MO) |
| Outfield | Mary Pardo | Ranger (TX) |
| Outfield | Nicole Weed | Daytona Beach (FL) |
| Outfield | Kim Crosby | Tallahassee (FL) |
| DP/Utility | Jessica Balsavich | Lake City (FL) |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Dina Medina | Phoenix (AZ) |
| Pitcher | Shelly Tayler | Jefferson (NY) |
| Pitcher |
Donna Coombes | Tallahassee (FL) |
| Catcher | Elizabeth Karabensh | Indian Hills (IA) |
| Catcher |
Angie Scharnhorst | St. Louis/Meramec (MO) |
| Infield | Janine Pollak | Mercer County (NJ) |
| Infield |
Jodi Otten | Central Arizona |
| Infield |
Shawnte Vallejo | Lake City (FL) |
| Infield |
Jessica Cerra | Tallahassee (FL) |
| Infield |
Dyani Leming | Crowder (MO) |
| Outfield |
Kristie Reid | Phoenix (AZ) |
| Outfield | Eboni Thompson | Jefferson (NY) |
| Outfield | Keri Shoulders | Crowder (MO) |
| Outfield | Julie Olinares | Independence (KS) |
| DP/Utility | Kelly Crosthwait | Johnson County (KS) |
| Third Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Catcher |
Allison Hunter | Johnson County (KS) |
| Catcher |
Molly Rawls | Illinois Central |
| Catcher |
Sarah Van Epps | Jefferson (NY) |
| Catcher |
Jennifer McKibben | Tallahassee (FL) |
| Catcher |
Angie Walker | Vernon Regional (TX) |
| Infield | McCall Fagan | Utah Valley |
| Infield |
Jen Yencho | Lackawanna (PA) |
| Infield |
Jennifer Cunningham | Gulf Coast (FL) |
| Infield |
Erica Connett | Illinois Central |
| Infield |
Stephanie Boyd | Crowder (MO) |
| Outfield |
Kelly Gay | Gulf Coast (FL) |
| Outfield | Tara Hill | Lake Michigan |
| Outfield | Sara Smith | Blinn (TX) |
| Outfield | Chere Gary | Pasco Hernando (FL) |
| DP/Utility |
Mary Jo Vrba | North Iowa Area |
