1998 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division II All-American Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Danielle Penner | California (PA) |
| Pitcher | Brenda Farrell | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| Pitcher | Karissa Hoehn | St. Cloud State (MN) |
| Catcher | Megan Hunsinger |
Bloomsburg (PA) |
| Catcher | Audra Thomas | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| First Base | Tara Douglas | California (PA) |
| Second Base | Trisha Poling | Southern Indiana |
| Third Base | Shelli Maher | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Shortstop | Stacy Dell'Anno | Merrimack (MA) |
| Outfield | Chrissa Landwehr | Augustana (SD) |
| Outfield | Jamie Peterson | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Outfield | Julie Garcia | Columbus State (GA) |
| Outfield | Sunny Litteral | Ashland (OH) |
| Designated Player | Stephanie Caldwell | Barry (FL) |
| Utility | Nathalie Fradette | Columbus State (GA) |
| At-Large | Lith Webb | California (PA) |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Natalie Pry | Ashland (OH) |
| Pitcher | Julianne Coleman | Florida Southern |
| Pitcher | Missy Paterson | Coker (SC) |
| Catcher | Laura Hansen | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Catcher | Dana Boyer | California (PA) |
| First Base | Jennifer Doolittle | Eastern New Mexico |
| Second Base | Jamie Sutton | Mississippi University for Women |
| Third Base | Kelly Norris | Coker (SC) |
| Shortstop | Robyn Kamisher | UC Davis |
| Outfield | Krissy MacLean | American International (MA) |
| Outfield | Jenny Hill | Augustana (SD) |
| Outfield | Becky Mancuso | Augustana (SD) |
| Outfield | Shannon McDonough | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| Designated Player | Courtney Watson | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Utility | Billi Kapla | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| At-Large | Julie Eggert |
Kennesaw State (GA) |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Shelly Owen-Martinez | Abilene Christian (TX) |
| Pitcher | Wendy Hurst | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Pitcher | Jessanne Kendall | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Pitcher | Chrisha Caldwell | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| Catcher | Michelle Daley | Assumption (MA) |
| Catcher | Amanda Jennings | Wayne State (MI) |
| First Base | J.R. Roberts | Cal State Chico |
| Second Base | Jennifer Jimerson | Missouri Southern State |
| Third Base | Carolyn McGowan | American International (MA) |
| Shortstop | Rhonda Matoska | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Shortstop | Sonia Harper | Valdosta State (GA) |
| Outfield | Andrea Heck | Shippensburg (PA) |
| Outfield | Steph DeLucia | Assumption (MA) |
| Outfield | Taiisha Pleasant | Humboldt State (CA) |
| Outfield | Shannon Ross | Kennesaw State (GA) |
| Designated Player | Jennifer Maupin | Tarleton State (TX) |
| Utility | Meaggan Wilton |
California (PA) |
| At-Large | Heidi Kriech | Augustana (SD) |
