1999 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Courtney Dale |
UCLA |
| Pitcher | Amanda Scott | Fresno State |
| Pitcher | Danielle Henderson | Massachusetts |
| Catcher | Stacey Nuveman | UCLA |
| First Base | Angela Cervantez | Fresno State |
| Second Base | Jennifer Lizama | Nebraska |
| Third Base | Ashlee Ducote | LSU |
| Shortstop | Amy Berman |
Southern Miss |
| Outfield | Jessica Mendoza | Stanford |
| Outfield | Becky Newbry | Washington |
| Outfield | Kim Pietro | South Carolina |
| Designated Player | Erica Beach | Arizona State |
| Utility | Amanda Freed | UCLA |
| At-Large (P) | Courtney Blades | Southern Miss |
| At-Large (1B) | Lynette Velaquez | Oklahoma |
| At-Large (OF) | Christie Ambrosi | UCLA |
| At-Large (OF) | Danielle Cox | Florida State |
| At-Large (OF) | Liza Brown | DePaul |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Nicole Terpstra | DePaul |
| Pitcher | Jamie Graves | Washington |
| Pitcher | Christa Williams | Texas |
| Catcher | Kellie Wiginton | Stanford |
| First Base | Julie Marshall | UCLA |
| Second Base | Kelsey Kollen | Michigan |
| Third Base | Julie Adams | UCLA |
| Shortstop | Kelly Kretschman | Alabama |
| Outfield | Catherine Davie | Michigan |
| Outfield | Tiffany Clark | USL |
| Outfield | Amanda Michalsky | Texas-San Antonio |
| Designated Player | Shavaughne Desecki | DePaul |
| Utility | Tarrah Beyster | Oregon State |
| At-Large (P) | Samantha Iuli | Illinois-Chicago |
| At-Large (P) | Kristen Hunter | Fresno State |
| At-Large (OF/P) | Kellie Wilkerson | Mississippi State |
| At-Large (C) | Kelli Bruce | USL |
| At-Large (P) | Brandee McArthur | Pacific |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Becky Lemke |
Arizona |
| Pitcher | Megan Matthews | South Carolina |
| Pitcher | Kelly Shipman | Maryland |
| Catcher | Stephenie Little | Cal State Fullerton |
| First Base | Traci Conrad | Michigan |
| Second Base | Nikki Cockrell | Texas |
| Third Base | Isonette Polonius | East Carolina |
| Shortstop | Lisa Carey | Oklahoma |
| Outfield | Becky Witt | Fresno State |
| Outfield | Nicole Giordano |
Arizona |
| Outfield | Autumn Eastes |
Texas |
| Designated Player | Carrie Moreman |
Alabama |
| Utility | Monica Triner |
South Florida |
| At-Large (P) | Kirsten Voak |
Arizona State |
| At-Large (OF) | Lauren Bauer |
Arizona |
| At-Large (2B) | Lovieanne Jung |
Fresno State |
| At-Large (C) | Kelli Metzger |
Akron |
| At-Large (3B/C) | Heather Stella |
Illinois State |
