1999 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kelly Schade | Simpson (IA) |
| Pitcher | Jessica Chambers | Messiah (PA) |
| Catcher | Jamie Lascik | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Catcher | Michelle Fowler | Simpson (IA) |
| First Base | Stephanie Carew | Chapman (CA) |
| Second Base | Tara Wisz | Montclair State (NJ) |
| Third Base | Krissy Medino | College of New Jersey |
| Shortstop | Andrianne Cole | Mt. Union (OH) |
| Outfield | Danielle Pease | Alma (MI) |
| Outfield | Valerie Kerkman | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| Outfield | Nicole Ceferatti | Buffalo State (NY) |
| Designated Player | Raquel Burns | Bethany (WV) |
| Utility |
Diane Naugle | William Paterson (NJ) |
| At-Large | Dina Terceira | Wheaton (MA) |
| At-Large | Jill Schoenike | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Becky Pierce | Alma (MI) |
| Pitcher | Kristine Zoch | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) |
| Catcher | Carrie Kuprycz | Bridgewater State (MA) |
| Catcher | Shannon Fritzke | Pacific Lutheran (WA) |
| First Base | Laura Remia | Ithaca (NY) |
| Second Base | Amanda Johnson | Chowan (NC) |
| Third Base | Danielle Guccia | St. John Fisher (NY) |
| Shortstop | Robin Mendygral | Wilkes (PA) |
| Outfield | Jennifer Meyer | St. Mary's (MN) |
| Outfield | Leanne Harris | Salem State (MA) |
| Outfield | Dawn Lopez | Chapman (CA) |
| Designated Player |
Tina Meyer | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| Utility | Kara Suhie | Keene State (NH) |
| At-Large | Cheryl Wah | Ithaca (NY) |
| At-Large | Jamie Elias | Rowan (NJ) |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Heidi Bergstrom | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| Pitcher |
Jessica Regan | Messiah (PA) |
| Pitcher | Kim Sears | Wheaton (MA) |
| Pitcher | Melissa Korb |
Pacific Lutheran (WA) |
| Catcher | Amie Flowers | Anderson (IN) |
| Catcher |
Carrie Scott |
Hope (MI) |
| First Base | Devon Searfoss | College of New Jersey |
| Second Base |
Sarah Lefke | Alma (MI) |
| Third Base |
Jennifer Lorenzen | Allegheny (PA) |
| Shortstop | Stephanie Allocco | Rowan (NJ) |
| Shortstop |
Angela Vecchione | Bridgewater State (MA) |
| Outfield |
April Harned | Salisbury State (MD) |
| Outfield | Cassie Cunningham | Capital (OH) |
| At-Large | Megan Hopper | Salisbury State (MD) |
| At-Large | Lauren Peloquin | Amherst (MA) |
