1999 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Amanda Larae Cave | Seminole State (OK) |
| Pitcher | Michelle Rowe | Lake City (FL) |
| Pitcher | Ashley Ivey | Tallahassee (FL) |
| Pitcher | Jennifer Lofton | Central Alabama |
| Catcher | Susan Campbell | Middlesex County (NJ) |
| Infield | Wendy Rochon | DuPage (IL) |
| Infield | Erica Shoults | Johnson County (KS) |
| Infield | Ketura Boykin | Lake City (FL) |
| Infield | Tonya Galiszewski | Union County (NJ) |
| Infield | Debbie Kupsko | Penn State-Hazelton |
| Outfield | Karen Smith | Indian Hills (IA) |
| Outfield | Alisa Steffen | Waldorf (IA) |
| Outfield | Lindsey Hodgen | Utah Valley State |
| Outfield | Monique Marier | Lake City (FL) |
| Utility/Designated Player | Maaike Ziljstra | St. Louis/Meramec (MO) |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Tara McClure | Indian Hills (IA) |
| Catcher | Jennifer Sabourin | Indian Hills (IA) |
| Catcher |
Jaci Welsh | Phoenix (AZ) |
| Catcher | Courtney Helcoski | Lackawanna (NY) |
| Infield |
Kayten Popelka | Kankakee (IL) |
| Infield | Daisy dePeinder | St. Louis/Meramec (MO) |
| Infield |
Martha Kelly | DuPage (IL) |
| Infield |
Gina Blackwell | DuPage (IL) |
| Infield |
Tracy Strohecker | Central Arizona |
| Infield |
T.J. Lambert | Kankakee (IL) |
| Outfield |
Angie Kenney | Phoenix (AZ) |
| Outfield | Brandi Walker | Lake City (FL) |
| Outfield | Melissa Martin | Gulf Coast (FL) |
| Outfield | Leslie Singley | Penn State-Hazelton |
| Utility/Designated Player | Janis McKay | Garden City (KS) |
| Third Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Nicole Kurth | Illinois Central |
| Pitcher | Lindsay Jones | Utah Valley State |
| Pitcher | Sandy Erickson | Cowley County (KS) |
| Catcher |
Karrie Sheehan | Lake City (FL) |
| Catcher |
Misty Faircloth | Louisburg (NC) |
| Infield | Amy Pickering | Central Arizona |
| Infield |
Kim Yencho | Lackawanna (NY) |
| Infield |
Andrea Marquez | Chattanooga State (TN) |
| Infield |
Jill Crawford | Chattanooga State (TN) |
| Infield |
Julie Emrick | Arizona Western |
| Infield |
Staci Brandon | Phoenix (AZ) |
| Outfield | Jennifer Herron | Three Rivers (MO) |
| Outfield | Meghan Maskel | Kankakee (IL) |
| Outfield | Marcie Villa | Hill (TX) |
| Outfield |
Jeanne Manz | Seminole State (OK) |
| Utility/Designated Player |
Amanda Serpas | Central Alabama |
