Louisville Slugger/NFCA 2000 NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Kathy Iggulden | Simon Fraser (BC) |
| Pitcher | Sonia Ortiz | Oklahoma City |
| Pitcher | Rachel Murray | Union (TN) |
| Catcher | Cheryl Bond | Nova Southeastern (FL) |
| Catcher | Kathy Spies | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Infield | Angela Lichty | Simon Fraser (BC) |
| Infield | Stacy Anderson | Union (TN) |
| Infield |
Tara Gaines | Columbia (MO) |
| Infield |
Christie Liu | Oklahoma City |
| Infield |
Loralyn Hinze | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Outfield |
Amy Vanderpool | Oklahoma Christian |
| Outfield | Juli Bodenbender | Simon Fraser (BC) |
| Outfield | Christine Phillips | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Outfield |
Lorna Lyttle | Azusa Pacific (CA) |
| DP |
Kelly Secord | Bellevue (NE) |
| Utility |
Megan Webber | Oregon Tech |
| At-Large | Kara Winkler | North Georgia |
| At-Large |
Natalie Buitink | Columbia (MO) |
| At-Large |
Leah Carrell | Oklahoma Christian |
| At-Large |
Amanda Dorow | Azusa Pacific (CA) |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Tara Brown | Cornerstone (MI) |
| Pitcher | Jodi Miller | Azusa Pacific (CA) |
| Pitcher | Erin Hall | Lipscomb (TN) |
| Catcher | Carly Millsap | Columbia (MO) |
| Catcher | Tiffany Kissee | Oklahoma City |
| Infield | Cristal Brown | Azusa Pacific (CA) |
| Infield | Rachel Abrams | Cal State Hayward |
| Infield |
Kristin Vanderlaan | Olivet Nazarene (IL) |
| Infield |
Lauren Hollis | Oklahoma City |
| Infield |
Kacy Lassere | William Carey (MS) |
| Outfield | Jan Yukumoto | Cal State Hayward |
| Outfield | Jessica Kraft | North Georgia |
| Outfield | Kelly Cleek | Olivet Nazarene (IL) |
| Outfield |
Danna Gilbert | McKendree (IL) |
| DP | Erin Moreland | Olivet Nazarene (IL) |
| Utility |
Kelli Dobbins | Lipscomb (TN) |
| At-Large | Jayne Miller | Columbia (MO) |
| At-Large |
Jamie Kemper | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| At-Large |
Michelle Gardner | Union (TN) |
| At-Large |
Aime Strahm | Point Loma Nazarene (CA) |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| At-Large | Kris Dugan | St. Xavier (IL) |
| At-Large |
Hew Miller | Faulkner (AL) |
| At-Large |
Jana Sagara | Menlo (CA) |
| At-Large |
Cheryl Bolding | Point Loma Nazarene (CA) |
| At-Large |
Jessica Mackey | William Woods (MO) |
| At-Large |
Kristina Jones | Columbia (MO) |
| At-Large |
Sarah Shivler | Indiana Wesleyan |
| At-Large |
Rebecca Cobb | Oklahoma Christian |
| At-Large |
Tara Adams | Columbia (MO) |
| At-Large |
Rhonda Barido | Athens State (AL) |
