2003 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Libby Hysell |
Central (Iowa) |
| Pitcher | Erica Hoyt |
Muskingum (Ohio) |
| Catcher | Sarah Tarasewicz |
Wisconsin-Superior |
| Catcher | Gina Utecht | St. Thomas (Minn.) |
| First Base | Mandy Carnes | Muskingum (Ohio) |
| Second Base | Alissa Mildebrath | Lake Forest (Ill.) |
| Third Base | Lisa Gentilella |
Salisbury (Md.) |
| Shortstop | Gina Meza |
LaVerne (Calif.) |
| Outfield | Jennifer Kypta |
Maryville (Mo.) |
| Outfield | Brynn Hasse |
Illinois Wesleyan |
| Outfield | Tamara Boggs | Emory (Ga.) |
| Designated Player | Nicole Blubaugh |
Muskingum (Ohio) |
| Utility | Jewel Koury | Pacific Lutheran (Wash.) |
| At-Large | Katie Mullinix | Salisbury (Md.) |
| At-Large | Sue Whitcher | LaVerne (Calif.) |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Lacey Lister |
Salisbury (Md.) |
| Pitcher | Jackie Demling |
Wheaton (Mass.) |
| Catcher | Mary Nicol |
Emory (Ga.) |
| Catcher | Nicole Loudin |
Baldwin-Wallace (Ohio) |
| First Base | Allison Gerrish | Springfield College (Mass.) |
| Second Base | Maren Schrader | Wheaton (Mass.) |
| Third Base | Kari McDonnell |
Montclair State (N.J.) |
| Shortstop | Heather Bortz | Moravian (Pa.) |
| Outfield | Lara Stone |
Cortland State (N.Y.) |
| Outfield | Michelle Mumma |
Messiah (Pa.) |
| Outfield | Mandy Smith |
Emory and Henry (Va.) |
| Designated Player |
Kameron Tucker | Bridgewater State (Mass.) |
| Utility | Audrey Lenoch | Gustavus Adolphus (Minn.) |
| At-Large | Jill Van Wychen |
Wisconsin-Stevens Point |
| At-Large | Kim Jeffs |
Plymouth State (N.H.) |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| At-Large | Hannah Roberts |
University of Chicago (Ill.) |
| At-Large |
Angela Gonzales | East Texas Baptist |
| At-Large |
Erin O'Connell | Wisconsin-Stout |
| At-Large | Amanda Gage |
Hamline (Minn.) |
| At-Large |
Kristen Lideen | Augsburg (Minn.) |
| At-Large |
Julie Gentner |
Cortland State (N.Y.) |
| At-Large |
Amanda Carroll | Capital (Ohio) |
| At-Large |
Sarah Kahler | Simpson (Iowa) |
| At-Large |
Rachel Schafer | Bethany (W. Va.) |
| At-Large |
Kristen Wallace | Methodist (N.C.) |
| At-Large |
April Miller | Central (Iowa) |
| At-Large |
Liz Swary | Washington (Mo.) |
| At-Large | Rita Horning | Cabrini (Pa.) |
| At-Large | Robin O'Connor | Roanoke (Va.) |
| At-Large | Kim Comtois | Brockport State (N.Y.) |
