2003 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division II All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Battery | Chris McGee | Phoenix College |
| Battery | Sonia Medina | Phoenix College |
| Battery | Emily Alsup | Parkland |
| Battery | Leigh Farina | Kankakee |
| Battery | Janet Barker | Muscatine |
| Infield | Diana Mendez | Phoenix College |
| Infield | Brandi Vondenstein | Northeast Mississippi |
| Infield | Lacey Frankland | Parkland |
| Infield | Meagan Koehler | Kankakee |
| Infield | Heidi Hart | Muscatine |
| Outfield | Delane Oscarson | Phoenix College |
| Outfield | Becky Wheeler | Parkland |
| Outfield | Boog Thurman | Kankakee |
| Outfield | Erin James | Parkland |
| DP/Utility | Nicole Wood | Kirkwood |
| Second Team | ||
| Position |
Name | School |
| Battery | Stephanie Elliot | Jefferson State |
| Battery | Jocelyn McGolrick | Northeast Mississippi |
| Battery | Brandi Ramas | Muscatine |
| Battery | Carlee Hawkins | Kankakee |
| Infield | Christi McGuirk | Jefferson State |
| Infield | Sara Paape | Lansing |
| Infield | Lindsey Pleuss | Waldorf |
| Outfield | Charity Graham | Northeast Mississippi |
| DP/Utility | Deanna Camacho | Phoenix College |
