2003 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| At-Large | Michelle Block |
Dawson |
| At-Large |
Heidi Brooks |
Corning |
| At-Large |
Jessica Griffith |
Anne Arundel |
| At-Large |
Dottie Koempel |
Ocean |
| At-Large |
Katie Lavin | Gloucester |
| At-Large |
Kim Lofton |
DuPage |
| At-Large |
Brooke Lowman |
Dawson |
| At-Large |
Sami McDonald |
Dawson |
| At-Large |
Kristen Wheaton |
Corning |
| At-Large |
Tina Willis |
Anne Arundel |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| At-Large |
Casey Bradford |
Gloucester |
| At-Large |
Rachel Chandler |
Corning |
| At-Large |
Kaila Fowler |
Dawson |
| At-Large |
Ashley Granato |
Camden |
| At-Large | Anna Marshall |
Monroe |
| At-Large |
Shannon Maschelin |
DuPage |
| At-Large |
Beth Nyhlen | DuPage |
| At-Large |
Denise Schultheis |
Anne Arundel |
| At-Large |
Liz Spokas |
DuPage |
| At-Large |
Sarah Swartzendruber |
Hesston |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| At-Large |
Christina Bounelis |
Anne Arundel |
| At-Large |
Jill Diesel |
Monroe |
| At-Large |
Michelle Guadaguino |
Ocean |
| At-Large |
Kristen Hand |
Montgomery |
| At-Large |
Laura Harthan |
Dawson |
| At-Large |
Shondelyn Petit |
Gloucester |
| At-Large |
Chelsea Rathie | Dawson |
| At-Large |
Kim Spreng |
Monroe |
| At-Large |
Gabby White |
Corning |
