2004 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Monica Abbott | Tennessee |
| Pitcher | Alicia Hollowell | Arizona |
| Pitcher | Dana Sorensen | Stanford |
| Catcher | Kristen Rivera | Washington |
| First Base | Kim Wendland | Georgia |
| Second Base | Caitlin Benyi | UCLA |
| Third Base | Vicky Galindo | California |
| Shortstop | Christina Clark | Fresno State |
| Outfield | Nicole Barber | Georgia |
| Outfield | Caitlin Lowe | Arizona |
| Outfield | Iyhia McMichael | Mississippi State |
| Designated Player | Wendy Allen | Arizona |
| Utility | Jessica van der Linden | Florida State |
| At-Large | Gina Carbonatto | Pacific |
| At-Large | Autumn Champion | Arizona |
| At-Large | Brooke Mitchell | Louisiana-Lafayette |
| At-Large | Heather Scaglione |
Oklahoma |
| At-Large | Jamie Southern | Fresno State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Keira Goerl | UCLA |
| Pitcher | Casey Hunter | Florida State |
| Pitcher | Kristina Thorson | California |
| Catcher | Jessica Allister | Stanford |
| First Base | Vanessa Iapala | Oregon State |
| Second Base | Veronica Wootson | Florida State |
| Third Base | Phelan Wright | Arizona State |
| Shortstop | Jessica Merchant | Michigan |
| Outfield | Kaleo Eldredge | California |
| Outfield | LaDonia Hughes | LSU |
| Outfield | Kristen Zaleski | Texas State |
| Designated Player | Holly Groves | South Florida |
| Utility | Jessica Beech | Michigan State |
| At-Large | Peaches James | Nebraska |
| At-Large | Lauren Lappin | Stanford |
| At-Large | Nicole Motycka | Michigan |
| At-Large | Kristin Schmidt | LSU |
| At-Large | Julie Watson | Cal State Fullerton |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Jessica Kapchinski | Texas A&M |
| Pitcher | Kristen Keyes | Auburn |
| Pitcher | Jessica Sallinger | Georgia Tech |
| Catcher | Sara Dean | Auburn |
| First Base | Saskia Roberson | DePaul |
| Second Base | Tiffany Haas | Michigan |
| Third Base | Sara Larquier | Virginia |
| Shortstop | Lauren May | Cornell |
| Outfield | Christen Bedwell | Cal State Northridge |
| Outfield | Megan Ciolli | Notre Dame |
| Outfield | Leslie Klein | LSU |
| Designated Player | Amanda Rivera | Illinois-Chicago |
| Utility | Sarah Martz | DePaul |
| At-Large | Leigh Ann Ellis | South Florida |
| At-Large | Dominique Lastrapes | Washington |
| At-Large | Jackie McClain | Alabama |
| At-Large | Megan Meyer | Seton Hall |
| At-Large | Chelsea Spencer | California |
