2004 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division II All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kelley Tiesi | Shippensburg |
| Pitcher | Krystal Lewallen | Northern Kentucky |
| Pitcher | Katya Eronina | Armstrong Atlantic |
| Catcher | Crystal Krebs | Colorado - Colorado Springs |
| Catcher | Cambria McKay | Kennesaw State |
| First Base | Keri McKee | Kennesaw State |
| Second Base | Alexis Wing | Angelo State |
| Third Base | Kim Miller | California (Pa.) |
| Shortstop | Elizabeth Economon | Truman State |
| Outfield | Robin Martz | Lewis |
| Outfield | Amy Middleton | Kennesaw State |
| Outfield | Monica Garza | Tarleton State |
| Designated Player | Elizabeth Beyer | St. Mary's |
| UT | Stephanie Pinto | Alabama - Huntsville |
| At-Large | Megan Brown | Florida Southern |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kym Kling | St. Mary's |
| Pitcher | Corinne Reiser | Caldwell |
| Pitcher | Angela Slaugh | Western New Mexico |
| Catcher | Kissy Stepanova | Armstrong Atlantic |
| Catcher | Stefani Easter | Texas Woman's |
| First Base | Amy Beverly | Missouri Western |
| Second Base | Jenny Bakke | North Dakota State |
| Third Base | Veronica Garcia | St. Mary's |
| Shortstop | Gabrielle Rendon | California (Pa.) |
| Outfield | Sarah Kohlbrenner | Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Abby Velta | St. Cloud State |
| Outfield | Andrea Williams | Humboldt State |
| DP | Stacey Richardson | Armstrong Atlantic |
| UT | Becky Mezyk | California University of Pennsylvania |
| At-Large | Meloney Strohbusch | Wisconsin - Parkside |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Lisa Macki | Kennesaw State |
| Catcher | Tara Licuanan | Cal State Bakersfield |
| First Base | Katie Bryan | Abilene Christian |
| Second Base | Denyve Duncan | St. Leo |
| Third Base | Cindy Perry | Cal State Dominguez Hills |
| Shortstop | Teresa Flores | Texas Woman's |
| Outfield | Jaime Dacey | Shippensburg |
| DP | Brenna Eck | Shippensburg |
| UT | Christie Hill | Cal State Bakersfield |
| At-Large | Kim Fujimoto | Barry |
| At-Large | Stacy Oliver | Armstrong Atlantic |
| At-Large | Sarah Carlson | Winona State |
| At-Large | Mary Jaszcak | Lewis |
| At-Large | Lindsey Graham | North Dakota State |
| At-Large | Sonja Garnett | San Francisco State |
