2004 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division II All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Battery | Shannon McGrath | Meramec |
| Battery | Josie Lindgrin | Northeast Mississippi |
| Battery | Rachel Schwartz | Phoenix |
| Battery | Ramie Garcia | Phoenix |
| Battery | Leigh Farina | Kankakee |
| Infield | Korie Shawver | Parkland |
| Infield | Rachel Adams | Meramec |
| Infield | Chelsie Mesa | Phoenix |
| Infield | Paige Wright | Northeast Mississippi |
| Infield | Amanda Ward | CC of Rhode Island |
| Outfield | Samantha Zadel | Phoenix |
| Outfield | Cary Walker | Wallace/Dothan |
| Outfield | Mandy Kerr | Muscatine |
| Outfield | Brittany Nash | Parkland |
| DP/Utility | Brandy LaJeuness | Meramec |
| Second Team | ||
| Position |
Name | School |
| Battery | Janet Barker | Muscatine |
| Battery | Jessica Brubaker | Lansing |
| Battery | Lora Fisher | Parkland |
| Battery | Blair Potter | Wallace/Dothan |
| Battery | Holly Elliot | Wallace/Dothan |
| Infield | Cari Kinzebaw | Kirkwood |
| Infield | Ann Sievert | Muscatine |
| Infield | Colleen Roach | Kankakee |
| Infield | Kelsi Jensen | Chandler/Gilbert |
| Infield | Raliegh Odom | Meridian |
| Outfield | Margaret Lear | Muscatine |
| Outfield | Tracie Woodbury | Lansing |
| Outfield | Ashley Bray | Phoenix |
| Outfield | Staranna Frazier | Northeast Mississippi |
| DP/Utility | Mallory Benak | Wallace/Dothan |
