2005 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Monica Abbott | Tennessee |
| Pitcher | Cat Osterman |
Texas |
| Pitcher | Jennie Ritter |
Michigan |
| Catcher | Kristen Rivera | Washington |
| First Base | Garland Cooper |
Northwestern |
| Second Base | Tiffany Hass |
Michigan |
| Third Base | Vicky Galindo | California |
| Shortstop | Courtney Bures |
Mississippi State |
| Outfield | Sarah Fekete |
Tennessee |
| Outfield | Caitlin Lowe | Arizona |
| Outfield | Marissa Nichols |
UNLV |
| Designated Player | Cameron Astiazaran |
Illinois-Chicago |
| Utility | Amanda Scarborough |
Texas A&M |
| At-Large | Kristie Fox |
Arizona |
| At-Large | Brianne McGowan |
Oregon State |
| At-Large | Heather Scaglione |
Oklahoma |
| At-Large | Kim Wendland | Georgia |
| At-Large | Jamie Southern |
Fresno State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Michelle Green |
Georgia |
| Pitcher | Alicia Hollowell |
Arizona |
| Pitcher | Kristina Thorson | California |
| Catcher | Ashley Courtney |
Alabama |
| First Base | Jennifer Curtier |
Pacific |
| Second Base | Caitlin Benyi | UCLA |
| Third Base | Kristi Durant |
Tennessee |
| Shortstop | Amber Jackson |
Bethune-Cookman |
| Outfield | Catalina Morris |
Stanford |
| Outfield | Kristin Vesely |
Oklahoma |
| Outfield | Harmony Schwethelm |
Baylor |
| Designated Player | Megan Gibson |
Texas A&M |
| Utility | Holly Currie |
Auburn |
| At-Large | Stephanie Churchwell |
Northwestern |
| At-Large | Angelica Selden |
UCLA |
| At-Large | Lindsay Schutzler |
Tennessee |
| At-Large | Michelle Smith |
Stanford |
| At-Large | Stephanie VanBrakle | Alabama |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Megan Meyer |
Seton Hall |
| Pitcher | Sarah Pauly |
Texas A&M - Corpus Christi |
| Pitcher | Jessica Sallinger |
Georgia Tech |
| Catcher | Rachel Folden |
Marshall |
| First Base | Page Jones |
Auburn |
| Second Base | Anne Steffan |
Nebraska |
| Third Base | Norrelle Dickson |
Oklahoma |
| Shortstop | Jessica Merchant |
Michigan |
| Outfield | Megan Ciolli |
Notre Dame |
| Outfield | Danyele Gomez |
Louisiana-Lafayette |
| Outfield | Tiffany Stewart |
South Florida |
| Designated Player | Nicole Motycka |
Michigan |
| Utility | Ashley Esparza |
Penn State |
| At-Large | Lisa Birocci |
Iowa |
| At-Large | Kaleo Eldredge |
California |
| At-Large | Courtnay Foster |
Northwestern |
| At-Large | Lauren Lappin |
Stanford |
| At-Large | Saskia Roberson |
DePaul |
