2005 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division II All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Krystal Lewallen |
Northern Kentucky |
| Pitcher | Aimee Murch |
Lynn University |
| Pitcher | Sonja Garnett |
San Francisco State |
| Catcher | Sarah Carlson |
Winona State |
| Catcher | Liz Beyer | St. Mary's |
| First Base | Christina Rolla | Lynn University |
| Second Base | Ricki Rothbauer | Northern Kentucky |
| Third Base | Roni Garcia | St. Mary's |
| Shortstop | Jess Shepherd | Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Jaime Dacey | Shippensburg |
| Outfield | Krista Altom | South Carolina - Upstate |
| Outfield | Robin Martz | Lewis |
| Designated Player | Sara Roba | Bloomsburg |
| UT | Stephanie Pinto |
Alabama - Huntsville |
| At-Large | Keri McKee |
Kennesaw State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kelley Tiesi |
Shippensburg |
| Pitcher | Kristen Schmidt |
Concordia - St. Paul |
| Pitcher | Amber Browning |
West Florida |
| Catcher | Jenny Baaske |
Columbus State |
| Catcher | Sarah Costa |
Shippensburg |
| First Base | Amy Beverly |
Missouri Western |
| Second Base | Amy Dalmore |
Adelphi |
| Third Base | Cindy Perry |
Cal State Dominguez Hills |
| Shortstop | Tiffani Craft |
St. Mary's |
| Outfield | Kristin Spencer | Alabama - Huntsville |
| Outfield | Stephanie Leimbach | Northern Kentucky |
| Outfield | Elizabeth Corr | Shippensburg |
| DP | Christie Hill | Cal State Bakersfield |
| UT | Mariah Piper | Regis |
| At-Large | Crystal Krebs | Colorado - Colorado Springs |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Melissa Stevens |
Emporia State |
| Catcher | Cambria McKay | Kennesaw State |
| First Base | Katie Bryan |
Abilene Christian |
| Second Base |
Vanessa Rodriguez | San Francisco State |
| Third Base |
Tiffani King | Lynn University |
| Shortstop |
Ashley Parenteau | North Florida |
| Outfield | Jennifer Hunt |
Kennesaw State |
| DP | Theresa Campbell | Montana State - Billings |
| UT | Katie Krauth | Augustana |
| At-Large | LIndsay Spaziani | LeMoyne |
| At-Large | Tracy Motzny | Humboldt State |
| At-Large |
Malissa Magee | St. Mary's |
| At-Large | Katie Heintz | Saint Leo |
| At-Large | Dayna Groom | Minnesota - Duluth |
| At-Large | Ashley Cecil | Florida Gulf Coast |
