2005 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Taylor Petersen |
Aurora University |
| Pitcher | Michelle Schlichtig |
Rutgers University, Camden |
| Catcher | Brianne Haas |
Maryville University of St. Louis |
| First Base | Liz Swary |
Washington University in St. Louis |
| Second Base | Michelle Wong |
University of St. Thomas |
| Third Base | Prudence Kjontvedt |
California Lutheran University |
| Shortstop |
Jill Jeranko |
Chapman University |
| Outfield | Julie Gawronski |
Union College |
| Outfield | Jen Scavone |
Clark University |
| Outfield | Beth Rohlena |
Coe College |
| Designated Player | Nicole Blubaugh |
Muskingum College |
| Utility Player | Liz Sisca |
William Paterson University |
| At-Large | Amy Ernst |
Coe College |
| At-Large | Courtney Bongiolatti |
Tufts University |
| At-Large | Candace Graham |
Hope College |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Meagan Hennessy |
Moravian College |
| Pitcher | Laurel Sagartz |
Washington University in St. Louis |
| Catcher | Mary Jo Marquardt |
Pacific Lutheran University |
| First Base | Gretchen Reucker |
Pacific Lutheran University |
| Second Base | Kim Tackett |
Muskingum College |
| Third Base | Leslie White |
Salisbury University |
| Shortstop | Kristi Huegel |
University of St. Thomas |
| Outfield | Nadine Taylor |
Wilkes University |
| Outfield | Amy Vukovich |
Washington University in St. Louis |
| Outfield | Jessica Regnerus |
Hope College |
| Designated Player | Laura Fencik |
Arcadia University |
| Utility |
Marissa Essner |
Maryville University in St. Louis |
| At-Large | Robyn Savitske |
Endicott College |
| At-Large | Lacey Lister |
Salisbury University |
| At-Large | Heather Bortz |
Moravian College |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| At-Large | Adrienne Acosta | Methodist College |
| At-Large | Harper Cornell |
York College |
| At-Large | Hackie Shedlock |
Western New England College |
| At-Large | Athanasia Totaro |
Montclair State University |
| At-Large | Maggie Wilder |
Chapman University |
| At-Large Base | Amanda Gage |
Hamline University |
| At-Large Base | Abby Arceneaux |
Union College |
| At-Large | Emily Adams |
Hope College |
| At-Large | Ashley Wagner |
Coe College |
| At-Large | Sadye Hill |
Hardin-Simmons University |
| At-Large | Maritza Padilla |
University of Redlands |
| At-Large |
Hannah Roberts |
University of Chicago |
| At-Large | Amy Iammarino |
Muskingum College |
| At-Large | Beth Shunkwiler |
Olivet College |
| At-Large | Amanda Baker |
Medaille College |
| At-Large | Danielle Lopez |
Tufts University |
