2005 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division I All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Allison Kline |
Hillsborough C.C |
| P | Angela Lopez |
Gulf Coast CC |
| P | Heather Robey |
Three Rivers CC |
| C | Blythe Golden |
Gulf Coast CC |
| C | Erin Slettvet |
Pima CC |
| IF | Sherri Rabenold |
Seminole CC |
| IF | Arica Rodriquez |
San Jacinto CC |
| IF | Lisa Parks |
Pima CC |
| IF | Ashley Monceaux |
Pima CC |
| IF |
Bridgette McNulty |
Central Arizona CC |
| OF | Brittany Walters |
Gulf Coast CC |
| OF | Danielle Smith |
Navarro CC |
| OF | Miriam Romero |
Pima CC |
| OF | Justine Pineda |
Central Arizona CC |
| DP/UTL | Kara Ross |
Central Arizona CC |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Rachael Foster |
Santa Fe CC |
| P | Lisa Newman |
Indian River CC |
| P | Lauren Eckerman |
Temple CC |
| P | Chelsey Lorenz |
Central Arizona CC |
| C | Jeaniel Pati |
Blinn CC |
| IF | Keidra Baitey |
Santa Fe CC |
| IF | Anadys Suarez |
Gulf Coast CC |
| IF | Marquesha Torres |
Western Oklahoma CC |
| IF | Brittany Tucker |
San Jacinto CC |
| IF | Kristie Kelly |
Central Arizona CC |
| OF | Deidra Baitey |
Santa Fe CC |
| OF | Sherrel Fountain |
St. Petersburg CC |
| OF | Melody Murphy |
Northern Oklahoma CC |
| OF | Ashlee Ackerman |
Arizona Western CC |
| DP/UTL | Jessica Mendenhall |
Indian River CC |
| Third Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Cassie Heller |
Indian Hills CC |
| P | Nicole Johnson | Pima CC |
| P | Karina Cannon |
Odessa CC |
| C | Alyssa Miller |
Western Oklahoma CC |
| C | Emily Robinson |
Arizona Western CC |
| IF | Heather Fox |
Central Alabama CC |
| IF | Melanie Denischuk |
Indian Rivers CC |
| IF | Ashley Jay |
Indian Hills CC |
| IF | Ariel Colburn |
Maple Woods CC |
| IF | Jennie Deitrich |
Odessa CC |
| OF | Joyce Roodenburg |
Gulf Coast CC |
| OF | Chanel Reaves |
Iowa Western CC |
| OF | Kim Chavez |
San Jacinto CC |
| OF | Rebecca MacLelland |
Lamar CC |
| DP/UTL | Cindy Smith |
Indian Hills CC |
