2005 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | June Jones |
Corning |
| Pitcher | Rebecca Pollack |
Sussex |
| Pitcher | Missy Flint |
Monroe |
| Catcher | Danielle Martinez |
Anne Arundel |
| Catcher | Nicole McDonald | Corning |
| Infield | Amber Stapler |
Anne Arundel |
| Infield | Kiera Zimmerman |
Middlesex |
| Infield | Hilary Dank |
Monroe |
| Infield | Kelly Unrein |
Dawson |
| Infield | Shannon Flanagan |
DuPage |
| Outfield | Amy Bush |
Anne Arundel |
| Outfield | Suzanna Fox |
Gloucester |
| Outfield | Holly Muys |
Sussex |
| Outfield | Sandy Niemeyer |
Dawson |
| DP/UT | Amanda Milner |
DuPage |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Jessica Carroll |
Middlesex |
| Pitcher | Rochelle Zook |
Hesston |
| Catcher | Joanna Hyland |
Camden |
| Catcher | Kristina Licursi |
Sussex |
| Catcher | Michelle Holtorf |
DuPage |
| Infield | Ashley Kimble |
Anne Arundel |
| Infield | Danielle Drost | Middlesex |
| Infield | Shawna Troyer |
Hesston |
| Infield | Dannielle Armstrong |
Dawson |
| Infield | Krystina Kirkwood |
DuPage |
| Outfield | Gladys Cabeza |
Corning |
| Outfield | Stephanie Chappine |
Gloucester |
| Outfield | Nicole Apgar |
Sussex |
| Outfield | Robyn Verhey |
Hesston |
| DP/UT | Cortnie Huggins |
Anne Arundel |
