2006 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Michelle Schlichtig |
Rutgers-Camden |
| Pitcher | Laurel Sagartz |
Washington University in St. Louis |
| Catcher | Nikki Conway |
St. Thomas |
| First Base | Erin Ruest |
Salisbury |
| Second Base | Erin Daniels |
Augustana |
| Third Base | Kelley Silagyi |
La Verne |
| Shortstop |
Carrie Embree |
St. Thomas |
| Outfield | Caroline Cubbage |
Lynchburg |
| Outfield | Annie Dillinger |
Fontbonne |
| Outfield | Nicole Cortez |
Hardin Simmons |
| Designated Player | Jackie Card |
Western New England |
| Utility Player | Maria Bye |
St. Thomas |
| At-Large | Lacey Lister |
Salisbury |
| At-Large | Laura Heise |
St. Scholastica |
| At-Large | Kari Hoying |
Muskingum College |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Colleen Oswald |
Rowan |
| Pitcher | Mallory McKinney |
Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| Catcher | Brianne Haas |
Maryville-St. Louis |
| First Base | Audrey Lenoch |
Gustavus Adolphus |
| Second Base | Jess Ferreira |
Suffolk |
| Third Base | Prudence Kjontvedt | NC Wesleyan |
| Shortstop | Ashlee Bass |
California Lutheran |
| Outfield | Kaitlyn Bowman |
Bridgewater |
| Outfield | Erin Duignan |
Mt. Union |
| Outfield | Amanda Jones |
La Verne |
| Designated Player | Andrea Carella |
Denison |
| Utility |
Arin Spence |
Hardin-Simmons |
| At-Large | Janet Nagle |
St. Thomas |
| At-Large | Meghan Gaskell |
Babson |
| At-Large | Christy Shipley |
East Texas Baptist |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Ashley Weaver |
Fontbonne |
| P | Stephanie Zwieg |
Plattsburgh |
| C | Kylee Brouwer |
Hope |
| 1B | Mari Valonis |
King's College |
| 2B | Stephanie Howe |
Wartburg |
| SS | Lorena Cernetisch |
Augustana |
| 3B | Lindsay Ware |
Bridgewater |
| OF | Emily Sunshine |
Emory |
| OF | Marissa Matis |
Aurora |
| OF | Erica Bond |
St. Scholastica |
| DP | Brittany Edelen |
Lynchburg |
| UT |
Amy Huling |
RPI |
| At-Large | Kaitlyn Dulac |
Ithaca |
| At-Large | Shelly Steinke |
Linfield |
| At-Large | Kristin Wallace |
Rowan |
