2007 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Maria Bye |
St. Thomas |
| Pitcher | Laurel Sagartz |
Washington Univ., St. Louis |
| Catcher | Hannah Shalett |
Ithaca |
| First Base | Carrie Embree |
St. Thomas |
| Second Base | Jenny Marshall |
Linfield |
| Third Base | Lindsay Sheppard |
Capital |
| Shortstop |
Jennifer Jimenez |
Monclair State |
| Outfield | Caroline Cubbage |
Lynchburg |
| Outfield | Autumn Millett |
Rutgers Univ. Camden |
| Outfield | Ashley Steines |
Wartburg |
| Designated Player | Caity Butler |
Bridgewater |
| Utility Player | Nicole Cade |
Ithaca |
| At-Large | Carolyn McCrea |
Monclair State |
| At-Large | Ronnessa Stampfli |
Univ. of Wisconsin Oshkosh |
| At-Large | Jamie Neuner |
Cortland State |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Nicole Riley |
Rhode Island College |
| Pitcher | Arin Spence |
Hardin-Simmons |
| Catcher | Tami Magner |
Luther |
| First Base | Sadye Hill |
Hardin-Simmons |
| Second Base | Stephanie Howe |
Wartburg |
| Third Base | Jackie Ferranti |
Montclair State |
| Shortstop | Lisa Huinker |
Luther |
| Outfield | Rebekah Kelly |
Methodist |
| Outfield | Amy Gahl |
Univ. Wisconsin, Whitewater |
| Outfield | Annmarie Nelson |
Cortland |
| Designated Player | Carter Malouf |
Washington Univ., St. Louis |
| Utility |
Rilee Dawson |
Scholastica |
| At-Large | Maria DeBonis |
Moravian |
| At-Large | Ellie Schultz |
Coe |
| At-Large | Maggie Wilder |
Chapman |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Megan Soultz |
DePauw University |
| Pitcher | Jenna Harvey |
Wellesley |
| Catcher | Laura Barry |
Bridgewater College |
| First Base |
Jessica DePolito |
Wheaton |
| Second Base |
Ali Braverman |
Emory |
| Third Base |
Ashley Hoffman |
Luther |
| Shortstop | Kelly Waskeiwicz |
Salisbury |
| Outfield | Tina Mangola |
Ohio Northern |
| Outfield | Erin Dudzinski |
Chapman |
| Outfield | Stephanie Rice |
Linfield |
| Designated Player |
Laura Fencik |
Arcadia |
| Utility |
Angela Sebasto |
Neumann |
| At-Large | Laurie Agresti |
Wilkes |
| At-Large | Kari Hoying |
Muskingum |
| At-Large | Casey Sullivan |
Tufts |
