Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division
2009 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kelsi Dunne | Alabama |
| Pitcher | Danielle Lawrie | Washington |
| Pitcher | Stacey Nelson | Florida |
| Catcher | Chelsea Bramlett | Mississippi State |
| First Base | Adrienne Monka | Northwestern |
| Second Base | Ashley Charters | Washington |
| Third Base | Alisa Goler | Georgia |
| Shortstop | Tammy Williams | Northwestern |
| Outfield | Kaitlin Cochran | Arizona State |
| Outfield | Brittany Lastrapes | Arizona |
| Outfield | Katie Schroeder | UCLA |
| UT/P | Megan Langenfeld | UCLA |
| UT/Non-P | Amber Flores | Oklahoma |
| At-Large/OF | Alissa Haber | Stanford |
| At-Large/UT-P | Charlotte Morgan | Alabama |
| At-Large/P | Nikki Nemitz | Michigan |
| At-Large/P | Missy Penna | Stanford |
| At-Large/OF | Taylor Schlopy | Georgia |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Brandice Balschmitter | Massachusetts |
| Pitcher | Stephanie Brombacher | Florida |
| Pitcher | Brittany Weil | Iowa |
| Catcher | Melissa Roth | Louisville |
| First Base | Tiffany Huff | Tennessee |
| Second Base | Aja Paculba | Florida |
| Third Base | Lindsey Ubrun | Missouri |
| Shortstop | Molly Johnson | Kentucky |
| Outfield | Kelsey Bruder | Florida |
| Outfield | Francesca Enea | Florida |
| Outfield | Brittany Rogers | Alabama |
| UT/P | Becca Heteniak | DePaul |
| UT/Non-P | Amanda Chidester | Michigan |
| At-Large/SS | Ashley Hansen | Stanford |
| At-Large/C | Sam Marder | Ohio State |
| At-Large/3B | Amber Patton | DePaul |
| At-Large/1B | Samantha Ricketts | Oklahoma |
| At-Large/UT-Non-P |
Maria Schweisberger | Missouri |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Sarah Hamilton | Florida State |
| Pitcher | Kim Reeder | Ohio State |
| Pitcher | Kristen Wadwell | Louisville |
| Catcher | Stacie Chambers | Arizona |
| First Base | Christine Lux | Notre Dame |
| Second Base | Danielle Zymkowitz | Illinois |
| Third Base (tie) | Cheyenne Jenks | Florida Gulf Coast |
| Third Base (tie) | Jenae Leles | Arizona |
| Shortstop | Bianca Mejia | Long Island |
| Outfield | Karli Hubbard | Louisiana-Lafayette |
| Outfield | Kirsten Shortridge | Louisiana State |
| Outfield | Carly Normandin | Massachusetts |
| UT/P | Danielle Spaulding | North Carolina |
| UT/Non-P | Jessica Mapes | Arizona State |
| At-Large/UT-P | Val Arioto | California |
| At-Large/2B | Amanda Kamekona | UCLA |
| At-Large/P | Tara Oltman | Creighton |
| At-Large/C | Jessica Purcell | Brigham Young University |
| At-Large/OF | Jenna Rhodes |
Virginia Tech |
