2009 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division II All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kristin Erb |
Lock Haven |
| Pitcher | Mandy Chandler |
Georgia College & State University |
| Pitcher | Sarah Phillips |
North Georgia College & State University |
| Catcher | Christine Roser |
Rollins |
| Catcher | Alisa Heronema |
Regis |
| First Base | Stephanie Denlinger |
Kutztown |
| Second Base |
Amanda Wilhelm |
Winona State |
| Third Base | Beth Lawson |
Alabama-Huntsville |
| Shortstop | Sara Lovestrand |
Florida Southern |
| Outfield | Courtney McGuire |
North Georgia College & State University |
| Outfield | Terra Halron |
Winona State |
| Outfield | Kristyn Lesovsky |
University of California, San Diego |
| Designated Player | Kayla Lewis |
Winona State |
| UT/P | Caitlin Lee |
Alabama-Huntsville |
| UT/Non-P |
Rachel Ruch |
Georgian Court |
| At-Large/OF | Mallory Kirchner |
Georgian Court |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Stacey Struzynski |
Winona State |
| Pitcher | Marjorie Johnson |
Southeastern Oklahoma State |
| Pitcher | Diana Sansevera |
Georgian Court |
| Pitcher | Nicole Anderson |
Rollins |
| Catcher | Jessica Shiery |
Abilene Christian |
| Catcher | Marissa Slattery |
Humboldt State |
| First Base | Sandy James |
Angelo State |
| Second Base | Emily Nieman |
West Virginia Wesleyan |
| Third Base | Andi Braswell |
Valdosta State |
| Shortstop | Macy Baker |
Angelo State |
| Outfield | Cassie Anderson |
Texas A&M - Kingsville |
| Outfield | Marsha Beaubien |
Saginaw Valley State |
| Outfield | Erin MacNamee |
West Chester |
| Designated Player | Megan Russell | University of Indianapolis |
| UT/P | Tara Reed |
Bloomsburg |
| UT/Non-P | Kristina Prater |
Alabama-Huntsville |
| At-Large | Natalie Galletly | Humboldt State |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Sage Woodham |
Alabama-Huntsville |
| Catcher | Jessica Strickland |
South Carolina-Aiken |
| First Base | Jessika Anastos |
University of Colorado-Colorado Springs |
| Second Base | Alix Dean |
Angelo State |
| Third Base |
Miranda Campbell |
Emporia State |
| Shortstop | Marti Littlefield |
Valdosta State |
| Outfield | Kasey Henderson |
West Texas A&M |
| At-Large/2B | Dana Webb |
Edinboro |
| At-Large/P | Jenna Vanacore |
LeMoyne |
| At-Large/P | Megan Leonard |
University of Central Missouri |
| At-Large/OF | Amanda Burkhart |
Southwest Minnesota State |
| At-Large/UT-Non-P | Alyssa Shirey |
Valdosta State |
| At-Large/UT-Non-P | Amanda DeCastro |
Pittsburg State |
