2009 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Ayrika Henderson |
East Texas Baptist |
| Pitcher | Jessica Stang |
University of Wisconsin, Whitewater |
| Catcher | Jamie Smrdel |
John Carroll |
| First Base | Kelli Dumistra |
Hope |
| Second Base | Donnalyn Cross |
Cortland State |
| Third Base | Jessie Atkinson |
Christopher Newport |
| Shortstop |
Liz Decima |
Ohio Northern |
| Outfield | Missy Bruggeman |
St. Thomas |
| Outfield | Alison Wright |
St. Thomas |
| Outfield | Whitney Wyly |
University of Texas, Tyler |
| Designated Player | Taylor Morgan |
Christopher Newport |
| Utility Player | Nicole Sabuda |
Buffalo State |
| At-Large | Jackie Sasko |
Rowan |
| At-Large | Staci Doucette |
Linfield |
| At-Large | Amy Gahl |
University of Wisconsin, Whitewater |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Katie Finch |
Cortland State |
| Pitcher | Brittany Miller |
Linfield |
| Catcher | Lauren Brenneman |
Salisbury |
| First Base | Kim Bandy |
Emory |
| Second Base | Anna Simonson |
Luther |
| Third Base | Meghan Reilly |
William Patterson |
| Shortstop | Kelly Waskewicz |
Salisbury |
| Outfield | Melissa Carlson |
LaVerne |
| Outfield | Maya Ripecky |
Tufts |
| Outfield | Whitney Tornow |
University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh |
| Designated Player | Rachael Everingham |
Central |
| Utility |
Megan Roo Richardson |
University of Texas, Tyler |
| At-Large | Molly Rathbun |
Eastern Connecticut State |
| At-Large | Claire Voris |
Washington University |
| At-Large | Rachael Click |
Gustavus Aldophus |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Angela Hartwig |
Wartburg |
| Pitcher | Rene Schwartzenburg |
Louisiana College |
| Catcher | Michelle Wlosek |
Springfield |
| First Base | Lindsay Cross |
Randolph |
| Second Base | Alex Hartmann |
Linfield |
| Third Base | Emily Keagbine |
Linfield |
| Shortstop | Jess Ferreria |
Suffolk |
| Outfield | Suzanne Gersich |
University of Wisconsin, Whitewater |
| Outfield | Kelly Koenigsknecht |
Alma |
| Outfield | Meaghan O'Gara |
Salisbury |
| Designated Player | Lena Cantone |
Tufts |
| Designated Player | Jennifer Kosinski |
DePauw |
| Utility | Nikki Franchi |
Willamette |
| At-Large | Beth Ameno |
Rochester |
| At-Large | Kelly Tomasek |
Adrian |
| At-Large | Ashley Leonard |
Coe |
