2009 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division II All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Ashley Meyer |
Iowa Lakes |
| Pitcher | Brianna Carpenter |
Lansing |
| Pitcher | Jacy Juden |
Cowley County |
| Pitcher | Hannah Dow |
Heartland |
| Catcher | Lacy Goodman |
Phoenix |
| Infield | Morgan Goddard |
Lansing |
| Infield | Brittany Martin |
Iowa Central |
| Infield | Stephanie Ochoa |
Iowa Lakes |
| Infield | Breayle Tackett |
Cowley County |
| Infield | Daniela Leal |
Pratt |
| Infield | Ashley Rosenberg |
Phoenix |
| Outfield | Carlie Schnoebelen |
Kirkwood |
| Outfield | Teddy Barry |
Phoenix |
| Outfield | Sarah Doyle |
Fort Scott |
| Outfield | Melodi Murrieta |
Lansing |
| DP | Tiffany Cupp | Lansing |
| Second Team | ||
| Position |
Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kylee Knop |
Kirkwood |
| Pitcher | Hannah Huebble |
Heartland |
| Pitcher | Stefanie Morong | Lansing |
| Pitcher | Ashley Spencer |
Cowley County |
| Catcher | Kashilia Young |
Cowley County |
| Infield | Terra Ramsey |
Danville |
| Infield | Tara Buchanan |
Kankakee |
| Infield | Kristina Manser |
Iowa Lakes |
| Infield | Christi Clevenger |
Johnson County |
| Infield | Brittany Hess |
Johnson County |
| Outfield | Sam Elmers |
Mercyhurst |
| Outfield | Lizzie Andrews |
Heartland |
| Outfield | Christy Cabrera |
Iowa Lakes |
| Outfield | Hannah Somer |
Fort Scott |
| Outfield | Jordan Wright |
Chesapeake |
| DP | Chelsea Parrish | Kirkwood |
Diamond Sports Catcher of the Year:
Lacy Goodman, Phoenix College
adidas Golden Shoe Award:
Ashley Willard, Iowa Central
