2009 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Amanda Cassella | Camden County |
| Pitcher | Megan Myers | Corning |
| Pitcher | Lindsey Grace | Monroe |
| Catcher | Danielle Davenport | Brookdale |
| Catcher | Danielle O'Rourke | Tompkins Cortland |
| Infield | Liz Gorges | Corning |
| Infield | Kristie Anthony | Camden |
| Infield | Danielle DePasquale | Glocester |
| Infield | Brianne Faynor | Brookdale |
| Infield | Erin Stankus | College of DuPage |
| Infield | Brandi Froman | Genesee |
| Outfield | Lauren Schramm | College of DuPage |
| Outfield | Brooke Wierzbicki | Tompkins Cortland |
| Outfield | Megan Becker | Gloucester |
| Outfield | Brittany McKerrow | Corning |
| DP | Jamie Mortlock | Rock Valley |
Diamond Sports Catcher of the Year:
Danielle Davenport, Brookdale
adidas Golden Shoe Award:
Gina Brenzo, Corning
