2010 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division II All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Sarah Phillips |
North Georgia |
| Pitcher | Casey Hanes |
Wayne State (MI) |
| Pitcher | Sherise Musquiz |
Hawai'i Pacific |
| Catcher | Kacie Easley |
Angelo State |
| Catcher | Alyssa Shirey |
Valdosta State |
| First Base | Kyrie Timbrook |
Caldwell |
| Second Base | Alix Dean |
Angelo State |
| Third Base | Miranda Campbell |
Emporia State |
| Shortstop | Kat Rivers |
Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Outfield | Danielle Monson |
Central Washington |
| Outfield | Kimberly LeComte |
West Texas A&M |
| Outfield | Mollie Bjelland |
Winona State |
| Designated Player | Kaycee Taylor |
Angelo State |
| UT | Lindsey Slocum |
Nebraska-Omaha |
| UT/Non-P | Dre Burnskill |
Mary |
| At-Large/3B | Jelena Shaw | UNC Pembroke |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Shavaun Fisher |
Bloomsburg |
| Pitcher | Kayla Jackson |
Arkansas-Monticello |
| Pitcher | Katie Petersen |
Midwestern State |
| Catcher | Brittnie Boerema |
St. Joseph's (IN) |
| Catcher | Kelsey Thompson |
Minnesota State Mankato |
| First Base | Kristen Drage |
Missouri S&T |
| Second Base | Danielle Lazorka |
Bloomsburg |
| Third Base | Amber Ingram |
West Florida |
| Shortstop | Samantha Ingersoll |
West Chester |
| Outfield | Jayme Hefler |
Lewis |
| Outfield | Kris Lesovsky |
UC San Diego |
| Outfield | Lauren Dykes |
North Georgia |
| DP | Beth Lawson |
Alabama-Huntsville |
| UT/P | Megan Russell |
Indianapolis |
| UT/Non-P | Dacey Hassey |
Northwest Missouri State |
| At-Large/C | Christine Roser | Rollins |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Breanne Gleason |
New Haven |
| Pitcher | Katie Goetzinger |
Wayne State (NE) |
| Catcher | Lacy Mauro |
Bloomsburg |
| First Base |
Katherine Martin |
North Georgia |
| Second Base |
Emilie Hobbs |
Arkansas-Monticello |
| Third Base |
Nicole Downs |
New Haven |
| Shortstop | Lauren Lopez |
Nova Southeastern |
| Outfield | Alison Allen |
Wayne State (MI) |
| Outfield | Sarah Hayslip |
Arkansas-Monticello |
| DP | Maile Kim |
Hawai'i Pacific |
| UT/P | Kristin Danielson |
Minnesota Duluth |
| UT/Non-P |
Ashley McSweeny |
Wheeling Jesuit |
| At-Large/C | Sarah Atkins |
Lenoir-Rhyne |
| At-Large/1B | Megan McCormick |
Indiana (PA) |
| At-Large/1B | Shannon Miles |
West Florida |
| At-Large/2B | Anna Bjorlin |
Concordia-St. Paul |
| At-Large/OF | Sarah DeMoss | Angelo State |
| At-Large/P | Torie Bunzell | Quincy |
| At-Large/OF | Melissa Medina | C.W. Post |
| At-Large/SS | Emilley McEwen | Cal State Dominguez Hills |
