2010 Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kim Lambert |
Luther |
| Pitcher | Molly Rathbun |
Eastern Connecticut State |
| Catcher | Tiffany Kruse |
Luther |
| First Base | Whitney Wyly |
University of Texas, Tyler |
| Second Base | Donnalyn Cross |
Cortland State |
| Third Base | Harmony Palmer |
Claremont-Mudd-Scripps |
| Shortstop |
Mary Alice Roy |
Louisiana College |
| Outfield | Joey Cronin |
University of Texas, Tyler |
| Outfield | Jodi Montagnino |
Louisiana College |
| Outfield | Whitney Tornow |
University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh |
| Designated Player | Alyssa Schrader |
Carthange |
| Utility Player | Karleigh Prestianni |
Linfield |
| At-Large | Staci Doucette |
Linfield |
| At-Large | Jackie Mangola |
Ohio Northern |
| At-Large | Jessica Rhoads |
Messiah |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Katie Finch |
Cortland State |
| Pitcher | Rene Schwartzenburg |
Louisiana College |
| Catcher | Karlee Quaritsch |
Augustana |
| First Base | Mary Margaret Boda |
Muskingum |
| Second Base | Christin Mickelboro |
LeTourneau |
| Third Base | Rhiannon Sorrentino |
Alvernia |
| Shortstop | Casey Sullivan |
Tufts |
| Outfield | Mandi Fought |
Ohio Northern |
| Outfield | Michelle Gravdahl |
Salisbury |
| Outfield | Sydney Marguardt |
St. Thomas |
| Designated Player | Luigina Facchini |
Western Connecticut |
| Utility |
Nicole Hedrick |
Alfred |
| At-Large | Kimi Blewett |
Ohio Northern |
| At-Large | Emilee Lepp |
Linfield |
| At-Large | Marta Radcliffe |
St. Thomas |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Hayley Feindel |
United States Coast Guard Academy |
| Pitcher | Kelly Leary |
Salisbury |
| Catcher | Amanda Frederick |
United States Coast Guard Academy |
| First Base | Alison Wright |
St. Thomas |
| Second Base | Anna Simonson |
Luther |
| Third Base |
Megan Mitchell |
Transylvania |
| Shortstop | Megan Fieser |
Univesity of Washington in Saint Louis |
| Outfield | Melissa Carlson |
LaVerne |
| Outfield | Ashley Peterson |
Saint Mary's College |
| Outfield | Bryn Worrilow |
Springfield |
| Designated Player | Emily Morris |
Bridgewater College |
| Utility | Whitney Dropsey |
Hiram |
| At-Large | Cara Montferrat |
Centenary |
| At-Large | Megan Soultz |
DePauw |
| At-Large | Katie Tenboer |
Central |
