2010 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | DeAnna Mock |
Rochester C&T |
| Pitcher | Christina Seppi |
Suffolk County CC - Selden |
| Pitcher | Katie Trotter |
Gloucester CC |
| Catcher | Val Karas |
Joliet Junior College |
| Catcher | Taylor Maurer |
Genesee CC |
| Infield | Jackilyn Ciran |
College of DuPage |
| Infield | Aryona Goodell |
Corning CC |
| Infield | Liz Gorges |
Corning CC |
| Infield | Brandi Froman |
Genesee CC |
| Infield | Anna Ramboldt |
Rochester C&T |
| Infield | Cherie Wangenstein |
Suffolk County CC - Selden |
| Infield | Samantha Carcano |
Suffolk County CC - Selden |
| Outfield | Gina Brenzo |
Corning CC |
| Outfield | Holly Frampton |
Corning CC |
| Outfield | Colleen Bannon |
Tompkins Cortland CC |
| Outfield | Brooke Wierzbicki |
Tompkins Cortland CC |
Diamond Sports Catcher of the Year:
Val Karas, Joliet Junior College
